López-Tarrida Ángela Del Carmen, de Diego-Cordero Rocío, Lima-Rodríguez Joaquin Salvador
Department of Critical Care and Emergency, Hospital Saint John of God Aljarafe, 41930 Seville, Spain.
Research Group CTS 969 Innovation in HealthCare and Social Determinants of Health, Faculty of Nursing, Physiotherapy and Podiatry, University of Seville, 41009 Seville, Spain.
J Clin Med. 2021 Nov 29;10(23):5612. doi: 10.3390/jcm10235612.
It is becoming increasingly important to address the spiritual dimension in the integral care of the people in order to adequately assist them in the processes of their illness and healing. Considering the spiritual dimension has an ethical basis because it attends to the values and spiritual needs of the person in clinical decision-making, as well as helping them cope with their illness. Doctors, although sensitive to this fact, approach spiritual care in clinical practice with little rigour due to certain facts, factors, and boundaries that are assessed in this review.
To find out how doctors approach the spiritual dimension, describing its characteristics, the factors that influence it, and the limitations they encounter.
We conducted a review of the scientific literature to date in the PubMed, Scopus, and CINAHL databases of randomised and non-randomised controlled trials, observational studies, and qualitative studies written in Spanish, English, and Portuguese on the spiritual approach adopted by doctors in clinical practice. This review consisted of several phases: (i) the exclusion of duplicate records; (ii) the reading of titles and abstracts; (iii) the assessment of full articles and their methodological quality using the guidelines of the international Equator Network.
A total of 1414 publications were identified in the search, 373 of which were excluded for being off-topic or repeated in databases. Of the remaining 1041, 962 were excluded because they did not meet the inclusion criteria. After initial screening, 79 articles were selected, from which 17 were collected after reading the full text. A total of 8 studies were eligible for inclusion. There were three qualitative studies and five cross-sectional observational studies with sufficient methodological quality. The results showed the perspectives and principal characteristics identified by doctors in their approach to the spiritual dimension, with lack of training, a lack of time, and fear in addressing this dimension in the clinic the main findings.
Although more and more scientific research is demonstrating the benefits of spiritual care in clinical practice and physicians are aware of it, efforts are needed to achieve true holistic care in which specific training in spiritual care plays a key role.
在对人们的综合护理中关注精神层面变得越来越重要,以便在他们患病和康复的过程中充分地帮助他们。考虑精神层面有其伦理基础,因为它在临床决策中关注人的价值观和精神需求,同时帮助他们应对疾病。医生虽然意识到这一事实,但由于本综述中评估的某些事实、因素和限制,在临床实践中对精神护理的处理缺乏严谨性。
了解医生如何处理精神层面,描述其特点、影响因素以及他们遇到的限制。
我们对PubMed、Scopus和CINAHL数据库中迄今为止的科学文献进行了综述,这些文献包括用西班牙语、英语和葡萄牙语撰写的关于医生在临床实践中采用的精神护理方法的随机和非随机对照试验、观察性研究和定性研究。本综述包括几个阶段:(i)排除重复记录;(ii)阅读标题和摘要;(iii)根据国际赤道网络的指南评估全文及其方法学质量。
在搜索中总共识别出1414篇出版物,其中373篇因主题不相关或在数据库中重复而被排除。在其余的1041篇中,962篇因不符合纳入标准而被排除。经过初步筛选,选择了79篇文章,阅读全文后收集了其中17篇。共有8项研究符合纳入标准。有3项定性研究和5项横断面观察性研究,其方法学质量足够。结果显示了医生在处理精神层面时所确定的观点和主要特征,主要发现是缺乏培训、缺乏时间以及在临床中处理这一层面时的恐惧。
尽管越来越多的科学研究表明精神护理在临床实践中的益处,并且医生也意识到了这一点,但仍需要努力实现真正的整体护理,其中精神护理的特定培训起着关键作用。