The NHS Business Services Authority, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom.
Department of Psychology, Northumbria University Newcastle, Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom.
Front Public Health. 2021 Nov 23;9:641424. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2021.641424. eCollection 2021.
Using digital technology to share patient-generated health data has the potential to improve the self-management of multiple long-term health conditions. Sharing these data can allow patients to receive additional support from healthcare professionals and peer communities, as well as enhance their understanding of their own health. A deeper understanding of the concerns raised by those living with long-term health conditions when considering whether to share health data digital technology may help to facilitate effective data sharing practices in the future. The aim of this review is to identify whether trust, identity, privacy and security concerns present barriers to the successful sharing of patient-generated data using digital technology by those living with long-term health conditions. We also address the impact of stigma on concerns surrounding sharing health data with others. Searches of CINAHL, PsychInfo and Web of Knowledge were conducted in December 2019 and again in October 2020 producing 2,581 results. An iterative review process resulted in a final dataset of 23 peer-reviewed articles. A thorough analysis of the selected articles found that issues surrounding trust, identity, privacy and security clearly present barriers to the sharing of patient-generated data across multiple sharing contexts. The presence of enacted stigma also acts as a barrier to sharing across multiple settings. We found that the majority of literature focuses on clinical settings with relatively little attention being given to sharing with third parties. Finally, we suggest the need for more solution-based research to overcome the discussed barriers to sharing.
利用数字技术共享患者生成的健康数据有潜力改善多种长期健康状况的自我管理。共享这些数据可以使患者从医疗保健专业人员和同行社区获得额外的支持,并增强他们对自身健康的了解。更深入地了解长期健康状况患者在考虑是否共享健康数据时所关心的问题——数字技术可能有助于促进未来有效的数据共享实践。本综述的目的是确定信任、身份、隐私和安全问题是否会阻碍长期健康状况患者使用数字技术成功共享患者生成的数据。我们还探讨了污名对与他人共享健康数据相关问题的影响。2019 年 12 月和 2020 年 10 月在 CINAHL、PsychInfo 和 Web of Knowledge 上进行了搜索,共产生了 2581 个结果。经过反复审查,最终确定了 23 篇同行评议文章的数据集。对选定文章的深入分析发现,信任、身份、隐私和安全问题显然是在多个共享环境中共享患者生成数据的障碍。实施污名的存在也成为跨多个环境共享的障碍。我们发现,大多数文献都集中在临床环境,而对与第三方共享的关注相对较少。最后,我们建议需要进行更多基于解决方案的研究来克服所讨论的共享障碍。