Bruno Antonio, Mattei Antonella, Arnone Federico, Barbieri Arianna, Basile Valerio, Cedro Clemente, Celebre Laura, Mento Carmela, Rizzo Amelia, Silvestri Maria Catena, Muscatello Maria Rosaria Anna, Zoccali Rocco Antonio, Pandolfo Gianluca
Department of Biomedical and Dental Sciences and Morphofunctional Imaging, University of Messina, Italy.
Department of Health, Life and Environmental Sciences, University of L'Aquila, Italy.
Clin Neuropsychiatry. 2020 Oct;17(5):263-270. doi: 10.36131/cnfioritieditore20200501.
Comorbidity in psychiatric patients has been widely examined in the literature, enucleating the role in misinterpretation of symptom's root in a multi-disease background, as well as the impact on the quality of life, outcome, and health-care effects. This research aimed to examine, in an Italian population of psychiatric patients, the diagnostic continuum in the context of lifetime psychiatric comorbidity, assessing possible differences related to the onset disorder.
A retrospective analysis of medical records of 458 subjects, in which various psychiatric diagnoses were represented and categorized in 16 nosographic classes, was conducted.
Results showed that "Bipolar disorder" (22.06%) was the most frequent diagnosis, "Eating disorder" had the earliest age onset (Mean age years = 16 ± 1.41), and "Schizophrenia" showed the longest disease duration (Mean years = 24.20±12.76). Moreover, 54,4% of the final sample presented at least one psychiatric comorbidity in disease history, while "Other personality disorders" was the most comorbidity-associated diagnosis, representing 29% of all the cases with more than 3 past diagnoses. Heterotypic transition was observed in fairly all considered onset diagnoses, exception made for "Schizophrenia" with 75% of the subjects showing homotypic progression.
Our results suggest a tendency to make multiple diagnoses over psychiatric patients' lifetime in the majority of cases, often escaping from the original onset nosographic domain. More generally, our findings agree with a broad consensus that describes psychiatric symptomatic dimensions rather overlapped and correlated with each other, leading to a more transdiagnostic clinical approach.
精神科患者的共病情况在文献中已得到广泛研究,阐明了在多种疾病背景下共病在症状根源误判中的作用,以及对生活质量、预后和医疗保健效果的影响。本研究旨在调查意大利精神科患者群体中终生精神科共病背景下的诊断连续性,评估与首发疾病相关的可能差异。
对458名受试者的病历进行回顾性分析,这些受试者有各种精神科诊断,并被分类为16个疾病分类类别。
结果显示,“双相情感障碍”(22.06%)是最常见的诊断,“进食障碍”发病年龄最早(平均年龄=16±1.41岁),“精神分裂症”病程最长(平均病程=24.20±12.76年)。此外,最终样本中有54.4%的患者在病史中至少有一种精神科共病,而“其他人格障碍”是与共病关联度最高的诊断,占所有有3种以上既往诊断病例的29%。在几乎所有考虑的首发诊断中均观察到异型转变,但“精神分裂症”除外,75% 的受试者表现为同型进展。
我们的结果表明,在大多数情况下,精神科患者一生中倾向于进行多种诊断,常常脱离最初的首发疾病分类范畴。更普遍地说,我们的研究结果与广泛的共识一致,即精神症状维度相互重叠且相互关联,这导致了一种更具跨诊断性的临床方法。