Schiff E, Koopman E J
J Psychol. 1978 Mar;98(2d Half):299-305. doi: 10.1080/00223980.1978.9915974.
The present study examined the relationship of women's sex-role identity to self-esteem and ego development. One hundred fifty-three female undergraduate students at the University of Maryland were the volunteer Ss for this study. During class time these persons completed the Index of Adjustment and Values, used to measure self-esteem, and the Sentence Completion Test, ussed to measure ego development. From this pool of Ss four sex-role identity groups were determined: androgynous women, feminine women, masculine women, and undifferentiated women. Twenty-five from each group were randomly selected to comprise a final sample of 100 women. Results of the self-esteem analyses supported previous findings that androgynous women possess a higher degree of self-esteem than stereotypically feminine women and undifferentiated women, but revealed no significant difference in self-esteem between androgynous and masculine women. In contrast, the level of ego development of androgynous women was not significantly different from that of feminine and undifferentiated women but was significantly higher than that of masculine women. Overall results support the theory that a combination of masculine and feminine characteristics is beneficial for women in terms of both self-esteem and ego development.
本研究考察了女性的性别角色认同与自尊及自我发展之间的关系。马里兰大学的153名本科女生是该研究的志愿者被试。在课堂时间里,这些人完成了用于测量自尊的《调适与价值观量表》以及用于测量自我发展的《句子完成测验》。从这些被试中确定了四个性别角色认同组:双性化女性、女性化女性、男性化女性和未分化女性。每组随机选取25人,组成一个100名女性的最终样本。自尊分析结果支持了先前的研究发现,即双性化女性比刻板的女性化女性和未分化女性拥有更高程度的自尊,但双性化女性和男性化女性在自尊方面没有显著差异。相比之下,双性化女性的自我发展水平与女性化和未分化女性没有显著差异,但显著高于男性化女性。总体结果支持了这样一种理论,即男性化和女性化特征的结合在自尊和自我发展方面对女性有益。