Simhi Meital, Sarid Orly, Rowe Heather, Fisher Jane, Cwikel Julie
Spitzer Department of Social Work, Ben Gurion University of the Negev, POB 653, Beer Sheva 84105, Israel.
The Center for Women's Health Studies and Promotion, Ben Gurion University of the Negev, Beer Sheva 84105, Israel.
J Clin Med. 2021 Dec 18;10(24):5952. doi: 10.3390/jcm10245952.
Cognitive-behavioral interventions can effectively treat symptoms of perinatal mood and anxiety disorders (PMADs). We assessed the acceptability and effectiveness of a workbook-based intervention (What Am I Worried About? (WAWA)) comprising of cognitive-behavioral and mindfulness techniques and weekly professional guidance to address symptoms of depression, anxiety, and stress among postpartum mothers. We compared the efficacy of group versus individual telephone consultation using a pre-and post-test single group, open trial, research design in replication pilot study. A convenience sample of community-residing postpartum women ( = 34) chose between group intervention ( = 24) or individual phone consultation with a mental health professional ( = 10). Outcome measures were anxiety (GAD-7), depression, anxiety, and stress (DASS21), and postpartum depression (PPD-EPDS). After four weeks intervention, significant reductions were observed in postpartum depression, anxiety, and stress scales. Cohen's statistics showed medium effect sizes (0.35-0.56). A small but significantly larger change in PPD-EPDS and DASS stress scores was reported among participants who opted for the phone intervention compared to those in the group intervention. Most participants felt that the intervention was highly beneficial and would recommend it to other postpartum women. In conclusion, the WAWA intervention showed efficacy for reducing postpartum anxiety, distress, and depressive symptoms among postpartum women, with a slightly greater reduction in PPD-EPDS and stress symptoms found among those who opted for individual phone consultation. Definitive evaluation of the intervention requires a larger sample and a RCT research design with two treatment arms: telephone and group intervention.
认知行为干预可以有效治疗围产期情绪和焦虑障碍(PMADs)的症状。我们评估了一种基于工作手册的干预措施(《我在担心什么?》(WAWA))的可接受性和有效性,该措施包括认知行为和正念技巧以及每周的专业指导,以解决产后母亲的抑郁、焦虑和压力症状。在一项重复试点研究中,我们采用单组前后测、开放试验的研究设计,比较了团体电话咨询与个体电话咨询的疗效。一个由居住在社区的产后妇女组成的便利样本(n = 34)在团体干预(n = 24)或与心理健康专业人员进行个体电话咨询(n = 10)之间做出选择。结果测量指标为焦虑(广泛性焦虑障碍量表-7,GAD-7)、抑郁、焦虑和压力(抑郁焦虑压力量表-21,DASS21)以及产后抑郁(产后抑郁筛查量表,PPD-EPDS)。经过四周的干预,产后抑郁、焦虑和压力量表的得分显著降低。科恩效应量统计显示为中等效应大小(0.35 - 0.56)。与团体干预组的参与者相比,选择电话干预的参与者在PPD-EPDS和DASS压力得分上有一个虽小但显著更大的变化。大多数参与者认为该干预非常有益,并会向其他产后妇女推荐。总之,WAWA干预在减轻产后妇女的产后焦虑、痛苦和抑郁症状方面显示出疗效,在选择个体电话咨询的人群中,PPD-EPDS和压力症状的减轻幅度略大。对该干预措施的确定性评估需要更大的样本以及具有两个治疗组(电话干预和团体干预)的随机对照试验(RCT)研究设计。