Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Zielona Góra, 65-046 Zielona Góra, Poland.
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Charité-Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Corporate Member of Freie Universität Berlin and Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin, 10117 Berlin, Germany.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021 Dec 17;18(24):13326. doi: 10.3390/ijerph182413326.
Medical humanity is an essential element of medical education, and the respective courses are introduced to the curricula of medical schools worldwide. However, significant differences in this type of medical education were identified in Italy, Spain, and the UK. In Poland, this issue was not yet analyzed. The classes offered on a compulsory and not elective basis secure the uniform skills of future physicians. Therefore, we were prompted to ask a question: do Polish medical students receive equal compulsory education in medical humanities? To answer that question, we performed a content analysis of mandatory classes' frequency, types, and content on medical humanization and communication in Polish medical schools. The study used publicly available information provided on the home pages of the universities to perform content and comparative analyses. Of 22 identified universities, 15 had publicly listed teaching programs, and nine had freely available syllabi. The names and types of courses varied from school to school. The number of hours the courses offered throughout medical education ranged from 15 to 216. In some medical schools, the classes were scheduled during the early, pre-clinical part of the study, whereas in other schools they were offered each year. The content of the courses always covered the topics of physician-patient communication but rarely offered protocols, such as the Calgary Cambridge guide. We conclude that the medical humanities represented by medical humanization and communication courses are included in the publicly available compulsory curriculum of most Polish medical schools. However, to secure equal education of future Polish physicians, there is a need to unify the medical humanities program.
医学人文是医学教育的重要组成部分,世界各地的医学院校都开设了相关课程。然而,意大利、西班牙和英国在这种医学教育方面存在显著差异。波兰尚未对此问题进行分析。必修而非选修的课程确保了未来医生的统一技能。因此,我们不禁要问:波兰医学生是否接受了平等的医学人文必修教育?为了回答这个问题,我们对波兰医学院校医学人文和沟通的必修课程的频率、类型和内容进行了内容分析。该研究利用大学主页上提供的公开信息进行了内容和比较分析。在 22 所确定的大学中,有 15 所公开了教学计划,有 9 所提供了免费课程大纲。课程名称和类型因学校而异。整个医学教育期间提供的课程时数从 15 小时到 216 小时不等。在一些医学院校,这些课程安排在学习的早期临床前阶段,而在其他学校,每年都提供这些课程。课程内容始终涵盖医患沟通主题,但很少提供卡尔加里-剑桥指南等协议。我们得出的结论是,以医学人文化和沟通课程为代表的医学人文学科被纳入了大多数波兰医学院校的公开必修课程中。然而,为了确保未来波兰医生接受平等的教育,有必要统一医学人文课程。