Department of Philosophy, Sociology, Pedagogy and Applied Psychology (FISPPA), University of Padova, 35122 Padova, Italy.
Emili Sagol Creative Arts Therapies Research Center, University of Haifa, Haifa 3498838, Israel.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2021 Dec 18;18(24):13338. doi: 10.3390/ijerph182413338.
This qualitative study was conducted in critical care units and emergency services and was aimed at considering the death notification (DN) phenomenology among physicians (notifiers), patient relatives (receivers) and those who work between them (nurses). Through the qualitative method, a systemic perspective was adopted to recognise three different categories of representation: 23 clinicians, 13 nurses and 11 family members of COVID-19 victims were interviewed, totalling 47 people from all over Italy (25 females, mean age: 46,36; SD: 10,26). With respect to notifiers, the following themes emerged: the changes in the relational dimension, protective factors and difficulties related to DN. With respect to receivers, the hospital was perceived as a prison, bereavement between DN, lost rituals and continuing bonds. Among nurses, changes in the relational dimension, protective factors and the impact of the death. Some common issues between physicians and nurses were relational difficulties in managing distancing and empathy and the support of relatives and colleagues. The perspective of receivers showed suffering related to loss and health care professionals' inefficacy in communication. Specifically, everyone considered DNs mismanaged because of the COVID-19 emergency. Some considerations inherent in death education for DN management among health professionals were presented.
这项定性研究在重症监护病房和急诊部门进行,旨在考虑医生(通知者)、患者亲属(接收者)和他们之间的工作人员(护士)在死亡通知(DN)方面的现象学。通过定性方法,采用系统观点来识别三种不同的表示类别:来自意大利各地的 23 名临床医生、13 名护士和 11 名 COVID-19 受害者的家属接受了采访,共有 47 人(25 名女性,平均年龄:46.36;标准差:10.26)。对于通知者,出现了以下主题:关系维度的变化、保护因素和与 DN 相关的困难。对于接收者,医院被视为监狱,DN 之间的丧亲之痛、失去的仪式和持续的联系。对于护士,关系维度的变化、保护因素和死亡的影响。医生和护士之间存在一些共同的问题,包括在管理距离和同理心方面的关系困难,以及对亲属和同事的支持。接收者的观点显示出与损失相关的痛苦以及医疗保健专业人员在沟通方面的无效。具体来说,每个人都认为由于 COVID-19 紧急情况,DN 处理不当。提出了一些与死亡教育相关的考虑因素,用于管理卫生专业人员的 DN。