School of Education and Social Work, Faculty of Education and Social Sciences, The University of Sydney, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Macquarie School of Education, Faculty of Arts, Macquarie University, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
BMC Womens Health. 2021 Dec 28;21(1):435. doi: 10.1186/s12905-021-01581-1.
It is estimated that less than one third of women (28%) worldwide, are not sufficiently active, and there is evidence indicating physical activity (PA) participation is lower during pregnancy and the postpartum period. Despite the importance of educating and encouraging postpartum women to engage in PA, existing systematic reviews have only focused on examining the impact of individually tailored PA interventions and on specific postpartum populations such as women who are inactive (i.e., do not meet PA recommendations) or women at risk of gestational diabetes mellitus or postnatal depression. This review aims to fill this gap by examining the impact of group-based PA interventions on postpartum women's PA levels or other health behavior outcomes.
A systematic literature search was conducted using four electronic databases (MEDLINE, CINAHL, EMBASE and PsychInfo) of published studies between 1st January 2000 and 31st October 2020. Studies were included if they targeted postpartum women with no current health conditions, had children aged 0-5 years, and engaged postpartum women in a group-based PA program that reported PA or other health behavior outcomes. Out of a total of 1091 articles that were initially identified, six were included.
Group-based PA interventions were moderately successful in changing or increasing postpartum women's self-reported PA levels and psychological wellbeing in the first 2 years of their offspring's life. Overall, group-based PA interventions were not successful in changing or increasing postpartum women's objectively measured PA levels, but only one study objectively measured postpartum women's PA levels. Narrative synthesis highlights the heterogeneity of the outcomes and methodologies used, and the low to medium risk of bias in the included studies.
To strengthen the evidence-base for group-based PA programs with postpartum women there is an on-going need for more rigorous randomised controlled trials of appropriate length (at least 3 months in duration) with an adequate dose of group-based PA sessions per week (to meet PA guidelines), and that utilise objective measures of PA. In addition, future PA interventions for this population should include, at the very least, fidelity and process data to capture the characteristics or design features that appeal most to postpartum women.
据估计,全世界只有不到三分之一的女性(28%)活动量不足,有证据表明,女性在怀孕期间和产后参与身体活动(PA)的程度较低。尽管教育和鼓励产后女性进行 PA 非常重要,但现有的系统评价仅关注检查针对个体的 PA 干预措施的影响,以及针对特定的产后人群,如不活跃的女性(即不符合 PA 建议)或有患妊娠糖尿病或产后抑郁风险的女性。本综述旨在通过检查基于小组的 PA 干预措施对产后女性 PA 水平或其他健康行为结果的影响来填补这一空白。
使用 MEDLINE、CINAHL、EMBASE 和 PsychInfo 这四个电子数据库,对 2000 年 1 月 1 日至 2020 年 10 月 31 日期间发表的研究进行了系统的文献检索。如果研究对象是没有当前健康状况的产后女性,其子女年龄在 0-5 岁之间,并且让产后女性参加基于小组的 PA 项目,报告 PA 或其他健康行为结果,则纳入研究。在最初确定的 1091 篇文章中,有 6 篇被纳入。
在其子女生命的头 2 年中,基于小组的 PA 干预措施在改变或增加产后女性的自我报告 PA 水平和心理幸福感方面取得了中等程度的成功。总体而言,基于小组的 PA 干预措施并未成功改变或增加产后女性的客观测量的 PA 水平,但只有一项研究客观地测量了产后女性的 PA 水平。叙述性综合强调了结果和使用方法的异质性,以及纳入研究的低到中度偏倚风险。
为了加强针对产后女性的基于小组的 PA 计划的证据基础,迫切需要进行更多的、适当长度的(至少 3 个月)、每周有足够次数的基于小组的 PA 课程(以满足 PA 指南)的、严格的随机对照试验,并且要使用 PA 的客观测量方法。此外,针对该人群的未来 PA 干预措施至少应包括保真度和过程数据,以捕捉最吸引产后女性的特征或设计特点。