Badon Sylvia E, Oberman Nina, Ramsey Maya, Quesenberry Charles P, Kurtovich Elaine, Gomez Chavez Lizeth, Brown Susan D, Albright Cheryl L, Bhalala Mibhali, Avalos Lyndsay A
Division of Research, Kaiser Permanente Northern California, 4480 Hacienda Dr, Pleasanton, CA, 94588, United States, 1 4152646944.
School of Medicine, University of California Davis, Davis, CA, United States.
JMIR Ment Health. 2025 May 22;12:e64507. doi: 10.2196/64507.
Strong evidence suggests physical activity (PA) can ameliorate postpartum depression (PPD) symptoms; however, many postpartum individuals do not meet PA guidelines. Electronic health (eHealth) interventions are a promising approach to address common barriers to PA during postpartum.
To test the effectiveness of a tailored eHealth PA intervention for increasing PA and decreasing depressive symptoms in individuals at high risk for PPD.
We conducted a randomized controlled trial within the Kaiser Permanente Northern California integrated health care delivery system. From November 2020 to September 2022, individuals 2-6 months postpartum at high risk for PPD were randomized to an eHealth PA intervention (n=50) or usual care (n=49). The eHealth PA intervention group received access to an online library of 98 ten-minute workout videos developed for postpartum individuals, including interaction with their infants. At baseline, 3 months, and 6 months postrandomization, surveys were used to assess depressive symptoms, PA, sleep quality, anxiety symptoms, perceived stress, and mother-infant bonding. PA was also measured using a wrist-worn accelerometer for 7 days at each timepoint. Primary outcomes were depressive symptoms and device-measured moderate-to-vigorous intensity PA (dm-MVPA) at 3 months postrandomization. Secondary outcomes were self-reported MVPA (sr-MVPA) at 3 and 6 months postrandomization and depressive symptoms and dm-MVPA at 6 months postrandomization. Intent-to-treat and modified intent-to-treat (excluding participants in the intervention group who did not watch at least 1 video) analyses were conducted using linear regression adjusted for variables used in the randomization procedure and using multiple imputation to account for missing data.
Participants were 4 months postpartum at baseline with moderately severe depressive symptoms (mean PHQ-8 [Patient Health Questionnaire-8] score=12.6), on average. Intent-to-treat analyses indicated no association between the intervention and change in depressive symptoms (mean difference=-0.9; 95% CI -3.3 to 1.5), dm-MVPA per day (mean difference=-4.5 minutes; 95% CI -23.5 to 14.5), or sr-MVPA per week (mean difference=3.8; 95% CI -1.9 to 9.5) at 3 months postrandomization or 6 months postrandomization (depressive symptoms: mean difference=-1.3; 95% CI -3.7 to 1.1; dm-MVPA: mean difference=1.3 minutes; 95% CI -18.9 to 21.5; sr-MVPA: mean difference=-1.8 MET-hours; 95% CI -7.7 to 4.2). Engagement with the intervention was suboptimal; although 52% (n=26) of participants allocated to the intervention group logged on to the intervention website and watched at least 1 video, the median minutes watched per week peaked at 10 minutes 2 weeks postrandomization, then fell to zero for the rest of the follow-up period. Results from modified intent-to-treat analyses were similar to those from intent-to-treat analyses.
An eHealth PA intervention tailored to postpartum individuals did not affect depressive symptoms or PA among those at high risk for PPD. Additional research to develop effective and engaging PA interventions is needed to help alleviate PPD symptoms and decrease PPD risk.
有力证据表明,体育活动(PA)可改善产后抑郁症(PPD)症状;然而,许多产后女性未达到PA指南的要求。电子健康(eHealth)干预是解决产后PA常见障碍的一种有前景的方法。
测试一种量身定制的eHealth PA干预措施对增加PPD高危个体的PA及减轻其抑郁症状的有效性。
我们在北加利福尼亚凯撒医疗集团综合医疗服务体系内进行了一项随机对照试验。2020年11月至2022年9月,将产后2至6个月的PPD高危个体随机分为eHealth PA干预组(n = 50)或常规护理组(n = 49)。eHealth PA干预组可访问一个为产后个体开发的包含98个10分钟锻炼视频的在线库,视频内容包括与婴儿的互动。在随机分组后的基线、3个月和6个月时,通过调查评估抑郁症状、PA、睡眠质量、焦虑症状、感知压力和母婴联结。每次测量时,还使用腕式加速度计测量7天的PA。主要结局是随机分组后3个月时的抑郁症状和设备测量的中度至剧烈强度PA(dm-MVPA)。次要结局是随机分组后3个月和6个月时自我报告的MVPA(sr-MVPA),以及随机分组后6个月时的抑郁症状和dm-MVPA。采用线性回归进行意向性分析和修正意向性分析(排除干预组中未观看至少1个视频的参与者),对随机化过程中使用的变量进行调整,并使用多重填补法处理缺失数据。
参与者在基线时为产后4个月,平均有中度严重抑郁症状(平均PHQ-8 [患者健康问卷-8] 评分 = 12.6)。意向性分析表明,干预与随机分组后3个月或6个月时的抑郁症状变化(平均差异 = -0.9;95% CI -3.3至1.5)、每日dm-MVPA(平均差异 = -4.5分钟;95% CI -23.5至14.5)或每周sr-MVPA(平均差异 = 3.8;95% CI -1.9至9.——此处原文sr-MVPA的95%CI数据不完整。5)均无关联(抑郁症状:平均差异 = -1.3;95% CI -3.7至1.1;dm-MVPA:平均差异 = 1.3分钟;95% CI -18.9至21.5;sr-MVPA:平均差异 = -1.8 MET-小时;95% CI -7.7至4.2)。对干预的参与度未达最佳水平;尽管分配到干预组的参与者中有52%(n = 26)登录干预网站并观看了至少1个视频,但随机分组后2周每周观看的中位数分钟数峰值为10分钟,然后在后续随访期的其余时间降至零。修正意向性分析的结果与意向性分析的结果相似。
针对产后个体量身定制的eHealth PA干预对PPD高危个体的抑郁症状或PA没有影响。需要开展更多研究来开发有效且有吸引力的PA干预措施,以帮助缓解PPD症状并降低PPD风险。