Anasuya Boligarla, Deepak Kishore Kumar, Jaryal Ashok Kumar
Department of Physiology, All India Institute of Medical Science, New Delhi, India.
Int J Yoga. 2021 Sep-Dec;14(3):188-197. doi: 10.4103/ijoy.ijoy_79_21. Epub 2021 Nov 22.
The intervention of yoga has been shown to improve autonomic conditioning in humans and better adaptability to orthostatic challenges. Similarly, slow breathing at 0.1 Hz akin to pranayama also increases baroreflex sensitivity (BRS). Hence, we intended to investigate whether yoga practitioners have different autonomic responses at rest,during slow deep breathingas well as during 6° head down tilt (HDT) compared to naive group individuals.
The aim of the study was to evaluate the acute effects of slow breathing on cardiovascular variability during HDT in yoga practitioners compared to yoga-naïve individuals.
This was a comparative study with repeated measures design conducted in Autonomic Function Test lab of the Department of Physiology, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Time domain and frequency domain parameters of heart rate variability, blood pressure variability (BPV), and BRS were evaluated during 6° HDT and slow breathing at 0.1 Hz on forty yoga-naïve individuals and forty yoga practitioners with an average age of 31.08 ± 7.31 years and 29.93 ± 7.57 years, respectively. All of the participants were healthy.
General Linear Mixed Model ANOVA was applied with yoga experience as a between-group factor in repeated measures. Independent sample -test was applied for between group comparison of respiratory rate, demographic, and anthropometric data. <0.05 is considered statistically significant.
Between-group comparison during HDT with spontaneous breathing has shown a significantly lower heart rate ( = 0.004) with higher RR interval (RRI) ( = 0.002) and pNN50% ( = 0.019) in yoga practitioners. The sequence BRS ( < 0.0001) and α low frequency (LF) of spectral BRS ( = 0.035) were also significantly higher in the yoga group compared to the naïve group. Similarly, during HDT with slow breathing, the heart rate was lower ( = 0.01); with higher RRI ( = 0.009); pNN50% ( = 0.048). Standard deviation of successive RR interval difference of systolic BPV was lower ( = 0.024) with higher sequence BRS ( = 0.001) and α LF of spectral BRS ( = 0.002) in yoga group than naïve group.
The yoga experienced individuals exhibit higher resting parasympathetic activity, lower systolic BPV, and higher BRS than naïve to yoga individuals. It is inferred from the findings that yoga practitioners were better adapted to transient cephalad fluid shift that happens during 6° HDT. Furthermore, acute slow breathing during 6° HDT reduced the systolic blood pressure in all the participants suggesting the beneficial role of slow breathing during exposure to extreme conditions such as microgravity which might help in the prevention of adverse effects of cephalad fluid shift during long-term weightlessness and maintain the astronaut health. Future mechanistic studies with active yoga intervention are necessary to understand the adaptive mechanisms involving central and vascular modulations contributing to either attenuation or accentuation of the cardiovagal baroreflex during HDT and slow breathing in healthy individuals.
瑜伽干预已被证明可改善人体的自主调节能力,并增强对直立性应激的适应性。同样,类似于调息法的0.1Hz慢呼吸也会增加压力反射敏感性(BRS)。因此,我们旨在研究与未接触过瑜伽的人群相比,瑜伽练习者在静息状态、慢深呼吸过程以及6°头低位倾斜(HDT)期间是否具有不同的自主反应。
本研究的目的是评估与未接触过瑜伽的个体相比,慢呼吸对瑜伽练习者在HDT期间心血管变异性的急性影响。
这是一项在印度新德里全印度医学科学研究所生理学系自主功能测试实验室进行的具有重复测量设计的比较研究。
分别对40名未接触过瑜伽的个体和40名瑜伽练习者在6°HDT和0.1Hz慢呼吸过程中,评估心率变异性、血压变异性(BPV)和BRS的时域和频域参数,他们的平均年龄分别为31.08±7.31岁和29.93±7.57岁。所有参与者均健康。
采用一般线性混合模型方差分析,将瑜伽经验作为重复测量中的组间因素。对呼吸频率、人口统计学和人体测量数据进行组间比较时采用独立样本t检验。P<0.05被认为具有统计学意义。
在HDT期间自主呼吸时的组间比较显示,瑜伽练习者的心率显著较低(P = 0.004),RR间期(RRI)较高(P = 0.002),pNN50%较高(P = 0.019)。瑜伽组的序列BRS(P<0.0001)和频谱BRS的α低频(LF)(P = 0.035)也显著高于未接触过瑜伽的组。同样,在HDT期间慢呼吸时,心率较低(P = 0.01);RRI较高(P = 0.009);pNN50%较高(P = 0.048)。瑜伽组收缩期BPV的连续RR间期差值标准差较低(P = 0.024),序列BRS较高(P = 0.001),频谱BRS的α LF较高(P = 0.002)。
有瑜伽经验的个体比未接触过瑜伽的个体表现出更高的静息副交感神经活动、更低的收缩期BPV和更高的BRS。从研究结果推断,瑜伽练习者能更好地适应6°HDT期间发生的短暂头向体液转移。此外,6°HDT期间的急性慢呼吸降低了所有参与者的收缩压,表明慢呼吸在暴露于微重力等极端条件下具有有益作用,这可能有助于预防长期失重期间头向体液转移的不良影响并维持宇航员健康。未来有必要进行积极瑜伽干预的机制研究,以了解在健康个体的HDT和慢呼吸过程中,涉及中枢和血管调节的适应性机制,这些机制有助于减弱或增强心迷走压力反射。