Department of Rheumatology, VieCuri MC, Venlo, The Netherlands.
Clin Rheumatol. 2022 Jun;41(6):1833-1841. doi: 10.1007/s10067-022-06073-7. Epub 2022 Feb 2.
Erosive Hand OsteoArthritis (EHOA) is a common rheumatological problem. We aim to determine characteristics of EHOA patients: comorbidities, radiographic erosivity and pain experienced after being diagnosed, in order to find which of these are potentially relevant in upcoming interventional trials.
Retrospective analysis of EHOA patients within the electronic database in one centre, with a telephone interview on pain as experienced even exceeding 12 months after being diagnosed.
Eighty-four non-academic EHOA patients were found: 89% females (median age 69 years), 11% males (similar age distribution). Kellgren-Lawrence (KL) erosivity scores in both sexes were comparable; DIPs scored higher than PIP's. Comorbid conditions were crystal-induced arthritis, rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and psoriatic arthritis (PsA) in 8%, 5% and 1%, respectively; seropositivity for rheumatoid factor and anti-citrullinated protein antibodies in 8% and 1% respectively. Pain worst experienced often exceeded a visual analogue score of 5.0, but was unrelated to the total KL score. Some pain reduction was reached with non-steroidals (perorally/transcutaneously) as deduced from continued use in 1 in 3.
In many EHOA patients, there is an unmet need regarding the treatment of pain, which per se was not directly correlated with erosivity score. Future studies may be designed considering the aforementioned characteristics, acting on the inflammatory process resulting in PIP/DIP erosions, with the exclusion of RA and PsA in order to get a clean study on EHOA. Several studies with monoclonal antibodies have been performed but demonstrated ineffectivity on the outcome of pain. Hope glooms with the arrival of innovative small molecules that may reach EHOA target cells. Key Points • Erosive handOA is a common problem in non-academic rheumatology; it is often associated with significant pain in both sexes exceeding a VASpain of 5.0 even years after being diagnosed; 1 in 3 found some relief in non-steroidals perorally/transcutaneously. • Future studies will have to focus on (episodic) inflammatory hand OA resulting in proven erosivity (EHOA) located in PIP plus DIP joints and may have to exclude comorbid active crystal-induced arthritis as well as rheumatoid/psoriatic arthritis and possibly even RF/ACPA seropositivity in order to get a clean study on EHOA. • As several big monoclonals have failed in EHOA, we may have to search for promising new drugs within the group of small molecules. These will have to show a significant pain-reducing effect and preferably also a disease-modifying osteoarthritis drug (DMOAD) effect.
侵蚀性手骨关节炎(EHOA)是一种常见的风湿性问题。我们旨在确定 EHOA 患者的特征:合并症、放射学侵蚀性和诊断后经历的疼痛,以便在即将进行的干预试验中发现哪些是潜在相关的。
对一个中心电子数据库中的 EHOA 患者进行回顾性分析,并在诊断后 12 个月以上进行电话采访,了解疼痛情况。
共发现 84 例非学术性 EHOA 患者:89%为女性(中位年龄 69 岁),11%为男性(年龄分布相似)。男女的 Kellgren-Lawrence(KL)侵蚀性评分相当;DIP 评分高于 PIP。合并症包括晶体诱导性关节炎、类风湿关节炎(RA)和银屑病关节炎(PsA),分别占 8%、5%和 1%;类风湿因子和抗瓜氨酸蛋白抗体的血清阳性率分别为 8%和 1%。最严重的疼痛通常超过视觉模拟评分 5.0,但与总 KL 评分无关。约三分之一的患者继续使用非甾体抗炎药(口服/经皮),表明疼痛有所缓解。
在许多 EHOA 患者中,疼痛的治疗存在未满足的需求,而疼痛本身与侵蚀性评分并无直接相关性。未来的研究可能需要考虑到上述特征,针对导致 PIP/DIP 侵蚀的炎症过程进行研究,排除 RA 和 PsA,以便对 EHOA 进行清洁研究。已经进行了几项针对单克隆抗体的研究,但都没有显示对疼痛结果的有效性。希望创新的小分子药物能带来新的希望,这些药物可能会作用于 EHOA 靶细胞。
关键点
• 侵蚀性手关节炎是一种常见的非学术性风湿病问题;它常与男女患者的显著疼痛相关,即使在诊断后数年,疼痛仍超过视觉模拟评分 5.0;约三分之一的患者通过口服/经皮使用非甾体抗炎药缓解了部分疼痛。
• 未来的研究将不得不专注于(发作性)炎症性手关节炎导致的已证实的侵蚀性(EHOA),位于 PIP 加 DIP 关节,可能还需要排除合并的活动性晶体诱导性关节炎以及类风湿关节炎/银屑病关节炎,甚至可能还需要排除 RF/ACPA 血清阳性,以便对 EHOA 进行清洁研究。
• 由于几项大型单克隆抗体在 EHOA 中的失败,我们可能需要在小分子药物中寻找有前途的新药。这些药物将需要显示出显著的减轻疼痛的效果,最好还具有治疗骨关节炎的药物(DMOAD)效果。