Striepe Stephan, Michaelis Anna, Markel Franziska, Kalden Philipp, Löffelbein Florian, Bollmann Andreas, Sepehri Shamloo Alireza, Dähnert Ingo, Gebauer Roman Antonin, Paech Christian
Department for Pediatric Cardiology, University of Leipzig - Heart Center, Strümpellstr. 39, 04289, Leipzig, Germany.
Department of Electrophysiology, University of Leipzig - Heart Center, Leipzig Heart Institut, Strümpellstr. 39, 04289, Leipzig, Germany.
Indian Pacing Electrophysiol J. 2022 May-Jun;22(3):131-136. doi: 10.1016/j.ipej.2022.01.007. Epub 2022 Feb 1.
This study evaluates the accuracy of iECGs in comparison to the gold standard ECG in adult patients with congenital heart disease and recommends the appropriate iECG derivation based on the patient's characteristics.
In 106 adults (51 female, 55 male) with congenital heart disease, a gold standard 12-lead ECG was recorded, followed by three iECGs with the Apple Watch series 4, which correspond to Einthoven leads I, II, and III. Two experienced and independent cardiologists analyzed the time intervals, amplitudes, and polarities of the ECG parameters as well as the rhythm type and correlated the patient characteristics with the iECG parameters.
The iECG parameters of all three iECG leads correlate strongly with those of the gold standard ECG, with exception of the P and T wave durations. We demonstrated that the informative value of the individual iECGs was independent of the patient's characteristics, in particular the heart axis, anatomy, and situs, even if the quality of the Einthoven III-like derivation was partially inadequate. The automatic rhythm analysis of the Apple Watch and the heart rhythm classification of a standard ECG analyzed manually by a cardiologist corresponded in 77%.
iECG recordings of adults with congenital heart disease provide comparable results with Einthoven recordings I, II, and III of the 12-lead ECG and current data encourage the use of the Apple Watch not only in patients with structurally normal hearts but also in patients with congenital heart disease.
本研究评估了在成年先天性心脏病患者中,单导联心电图(iECG)相对于金标准心电图的准确性,并根据患者特征推荐合适的iECG导联。
对106例成年先天性心脏病患者(51例女性,55例男性)记录金标准12导联心电图,随后使用苹果手表系列4记录三个iECG,分别对应于肢体导联I、II和III。两名经验丰富且独立的心脏病专家分析了心电图参数的时间间期、振幅和极性以及心律类型,并将患者特征与iECG参数进行关联。
除P波和T波持续时间外,所有三个iECG导联的iECG参数与金标准心电图的参数高度相关。我们证明,即使类似肢体导联III的导联质量部分欠佳,单个iECG的信息量也与患者特征无关,尤其是心脏电轴、解剖结构和心脏位置。苹果手表的自动心律分析与心脏病专家手动分析的标准心电图的心律分类一致性为77%。
成年先天性心脏病患者的iECG记录与12导联心电图的肢体导联I、II和III记录结果相当,当前数据鼓励不仅在心脏结构正常的患者中,而且在先天性心脏病患者中使用苹果手表。