McMahon Naoimh E
Division of Health Research, National Institute for Health Research School for Public Health Research (NIHR SPHR), Lancaster University, Lancaster, LA1 4YW UK.
Soc Theory Health. 2023;21(2):119-139. doi: 10.1057/s41285-022-00176-6. Epub 2022 Jan 31.
Local health systems are increasingly tasked to play a more central role in driving action to reduce social inequalities in health. Past experience, however, has demonstrated the challenge of reorienting health system actions towards prevention and the wider determinants of health. In this review, I use meta-ethnographic methods to synthesise findings from eleven qualitative research studies that have examined how ambitions to tackle social inequalities in health take shape within local health systems. The resulting line-of-argument illustrates how such inequalities continue to be problematised in narrow and reductionist ways to fit both with pre-existing conceptions of health, and the institutional practices which shape thinking and action. Instances of health system actors adopting a more social view of inequalities, and taking a more active role in influencing the social and structural determinants of health, were attributed to the beliefs and values of system leaders, and their ability to push-back against dominant discourses and institutional norms. This synthesised account provides an additional layer of understanding about the specific challenges experienced by health workforces when tasked to address this complex and enduring problem, and provides essential insights for understanding the success and shortcomings of future cross-sectoral efforts to tackle social inequalities in health.
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1057/s41285-022-00176-6.
地方卫生系统在推动减少健康方面的社会不平等行动中,承担的任务越来越重要。然而,过去的经验表明,将卫生系统行动重新定位到预防及更广泛的健康决定因素存在挑战。在本综述中,我运用元民族志方法,综合了11项定性研究的结果,这些研究探讨了在地方卫生系统中,解决健康方面社会不平等的目标是如何形成的。由此得出的论证思路表明,此类不平等如何继续以狭隘和简化的方式被问题化,以符合既有的健康观念以及塑造思维和行动的机构实践。卫生系统行为者采用更具社会性的不平等视角,并在影响健康的社会和结构决定因素方面发挥更积极作用的事例,归因于系统领导者的信念和价值观,以及他们抵制主流话语和机构规范的能力。这一综合阐述为理解卫生工作者在受命解决这一复杂且持久问题时所面临的具体挑战提供了额外层面的认识,并为理解未来跨部门解决健康方面社会不平等努力的成败提供了重要见解。
网络版包含可在10.1057/s41285-022-00176-6获取的补充材料。