Air Quality and Public Health Group, Environmental Hazards and Emergencies Department, Radiation, Chemical and Environmental Hazards, UK Health Security Agency, United Kingdom.
Air Quality and Public Health Group, Environmental Hazards and Emergencies Department, Radiation, Chemical and Environmental Hazards, UK Health Security Agency, United Kingdom.
Int J Hyg Environ Health. 2022 Apr;241:113926. doi: 10.1016/j.ijheh.2022.113926. Epub 2022 Feb 8.
Epidemiological studies performed in low- and middle-income countries have shown a positive association between solid fuel burning exposure and adverse health effects, including respiratory effects in adults. However, the evidence is less clear in other countries. We performed a systematic review of epidemiological studies conducted in Europe, North America (Canada and USA only), Australia and New Zealand on the association between outdoor and indoor exposure to solid fuel (biomass and coal) combustion and respiratory outcomes in adults. We identified 34 articles. The epidemiological evidence is still limited. Positive associations were found between indoor coal, wood and combined solid fuel combustion exposure and lung cancer risk, although based on a limited number of studies. A significant association was found between indoor solid fuel exposure and COPD risk. Inconsistent results were found considering indoor coal, wood and mixed solid fuel burning exposure and other respiratory outcomes (i.e. lower respiratory infections, upper respiratory infections and other upper respiratory tract diseases, asthma and respiratory symptoms). Inconsistent results were found considering the relationship between the exposure to outdoor wood burning exposure and overall respiratory mortality, asthma, COPD and respiratory symptoms in adults. The available epidemiological evidence between outdoor exposure to residential coal burning and respiratory outcomes suggests an increased risk of adverse respiratory effects. The studies considering the impact of the introduction of measures in order to reduce solid fuel burning on air quality and health showed an improvement in air quality resulting in a reduction of adverse respiratory effects. The identified epidemiological studies have several limitations. Additional and better conducted epidemiological studies are needed to establish whether exposure occurring indoors and outdoors to solid fuel combustion pollutants is associated with adverse respiratory outcomes in adults.
在中低收入国家进行的流行病学研究表明,固体燃料燃烧暴露与不良健康影响之间存在正相关关系,包括成年人的呼吸道影响。然而,在其他国家,证据并不那么明确。我们对欧洲、北美(仅包括加拿大和美国)、澳大利亚和新西兰进行的关于固体燃料(生物量和煤)燃烧的室外和室内暴露与成年人呼吸道结果之间关系的流行病学研究进行了系统评价。我们确定了 34 篇文章。流行病学证据仍然有限。虽然基于有限数量的研究,但发现室内煤、木材和混合固体燃料燃烧暴露与肺癌风险之间存在正相关关系。发现室内固体燃料暴露与 COPD 风险之间存在显著相关性。考虑到室内煤、木材和混合固体燃料燃烧暴露与其他呼吸道结果(即下呼吸道感染、上呼吸道感染和其他上呼吸道疾病、哮喘和呼吸道症状)之间的关系,结果不一致。考虑到室外木材燃烧暴露与成年人总体呼吸道死亡率、哮喘、COPD 和呼吸道症状之间的关系,结果不一致。现有的关于室外接触住宅燃煤与呼吸道结果之间的流行病学证据表明,接触这些污染物会增加不良呼吸道影响的风险。考虑到为减少固体燃料燃烧而采取的措施对空气质量和健康的影响的研究表明,空气质量的改善导致不良呼吸道影响的减少。已确定的流行病学研究存在一些局限性。需要进行更多和更好的流行病学研究,以确定室内和室外接触固体燃料燃烧污染物是否与成年人的不良呼吸道结果有关。