Hubert Department of Global Health, Rollins School of Public Health, Emory University, Atlanta, GA 30329, USA.
Department of Behavioral, Social, & Health Education Sciences, Rollins School of Public Health, Emory University, Atlanta, GA 30329, USA.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2022 Jan 21;19(3):1170. doi: 10.3390/ijerph19031170.
Women experiencing poverty are more likely to face intimate partner violence (IPV), poor health, and stigma. IPV survivors are overrepresented among those who receive Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), a conditional cash program serving families experiencing poverty. More generous TANF policies may be protective against IPV, but a greater insight into TANF's effect could be gleaned through a contemporaneous study that examines intersecting determinants of wellbeing and engages community interpretation of findings. Using an adapted Family Stress Model framework and analyzing data through an intersectional and community-based lens, we explore the impact of TANF on women's wellbeing through in-depth, semi-structured interviews during the COVID-19 pandemic with 13 women who had TANF experience in three U.S. states. Data were analyzed using thematic analysis in MAXQDA and researchers facilitated three member-checking events to enhance validity of result interpretation. Four themes emerged: (1) Low cash and conditional benefits provided limited short-term "relief" but contributed to poverty and hard choices; (2) TANF benefit levels and conditions increased women's dependence on others, straining relationships; (3) Women undertook extraordinary measures to access TANF, largely to fulfill their roles as mothers; and (4) TANF stigma creates psychological stress, differentially experienced by African Americans. Increasing TANF cash benefits and other cash transfers for those experiencing poverty, adopting solely state funded TANF programs, increasing funding for TANF administration, addressing TANF stigma and racialized narratives, and allowing optional child support participation or a larger "pass-through" of child support are important steps toward making TANF more protective against IPV.
经历贫困的女性更有可能面临亲密伴侣暴力(IPV)、健康状况不佳和耻辱感。在接受临时援助家庭(TANF)的人中,IPV 幸存者的比例过高,TANF 是一个为贫困家庭提供的有条件现金援助计划。更慷慨的 TANF 政策可能对 IPV 具有保护作用,但通过同时研究 intersecting determinants of wellbeing 并利用社区对研究结果的解释,可以更深入地了解 TANF 的影响。使用适应性家庭压力模型框架,并通过交叉和基于社区的视角分析数据,我们通过在 COVID-19 大流行期间对美国三个州的 13 名有 TANF 经验的女性进行深入的半结构化访谈,探讨了 TANF 对女性福祉的影响。数据使用 MAXQDA 中的主题分析进行分析,研究人员通过三次成员检查活动来增强结果解释的有效性。出现了四个主题:(1)现金和有条件福利低,提供了有限的短期“缓解”,但导致了贫困和艰难的选择;(2)TANF 福利水平和条件增加了妇女对他人的依赖,紧张了她们的关系;(3)妇女采取了非凡的措施来获得 TANF,主要是为了履行作为母亲的角色;(4)TANF 耻辱感造成了心理压力,非裔美国人经历的压力不同。增加 TANF 现金福利和其他为贫困者提供的现金转移、采用完全由州资助的 TANF 计划、增加 TANF 管理资金、解决 TANF 耻辱感和种族化叙事,以及允许可选的儿童抚养费参与或更大的“传递”儿童抚养费,这些都是使 TANF 更能预防 IPV 的重要步骤。