SEICHE Center for Health and Justice, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, USA.
Department of Behavioral and Social Sciences, Brown School of Public Health, Providence, Rhode Island, USA.
LGBT Health. 2022 Feb-Mar;9(2):81-93. doi: 10.1089/lgbt.2021.0090. Epub 2022 Feb 15.
To facilitate identification of the impact of incarceration on the health of sexual and gender minority (SGM) populations, we sought to identify publicly accessible, representative health datasets that assessed SGM status and incarceration history from 2010 to 2020 and to examine SGM disparities in lifetime incarceration experiences. Datasets were identified and analyzed through a multistep process: (1) content search of 76 health datasets; (2) consultation with 14 subject matter experts; (3) a systematic review; and (4) a data analysis stage. Utilizing the identified health datasets, we produced representative estimates of sexual minority (SM) incarceration disparities. Five publicly accessible databases were identified that assessed SM status and incarceration history; none assessed gender minority status and incarceration history. Across datasets, the weighted prevalence of lifetime incarceration among SM populations was substantially higher (range = 17.5%-26.3%) than among non-SM populations (range = 4.6%-21.2%). Few publicly accessible, representative health datasets collect standardized information regarding SM status and incarceration history, and none assess diverse gender identities and incarceration history. These data suggest that a disproportionate proportion of SM individuals may experience incarceration compared with non-SM individuals. Research assessing the health effects of incarceration on SGM populations remains limited; publicly accessible, representative health data are needed to address this gap.
为了便于确定监禁对性少数群体和性别少数群体(SGM)人群健康的影响,我们试图确定从 2010 年到 2020 年期间可公开获取的、具有代表性的评估 SGM 身份和监禁史的健康数据集,并研究 SGM 人群在终身监禁经历方面的差异。数据集是通过多步骤过程确定和分析的:(1)对 76 个健康数据集进行内容搜索;(2)咨询 14 名主题专家;(3)系统审查;(4)数据分析阶段。利用确定的健康数据集,我们产生了性少数群体(SM)监禁差异的代表性估计。确定了五个可公开获取的数据库,评估了 SM 身份和监禁史;没有一个数据库评估性别少数群体的身份和监禁史。在这些数据集中,SM 人群终身监禁的加权患病率明显高于非 SM 人群(范围为 17.5%-26.3%)(范围为 4.6%-21.2%)。很少有可公开获取的、具有代表性的健康数据集收集关于 SM 身份和监禁史的标准化信息,也没有评估多样化的性别认同和监禁史。这些数据表明,与非 SM 个体相比,SM 个体中可能有不成比例的人会经历监禁。评估监禁对 SGM 人群健康影响的研究仍然有限;需要可公开获取的、具有代表性的健康数据来解决这一差距。