Uchikoshi Fumiya, Conley Dalton
Princeton University.
Res Soc Stratif Mobil. 2021 Dec;76. doi: 10.1016/j.rssm.2021.100628. Epub 2021 Jul 16.
There is much evidence to suggest that family background and the context of secondary education both contribute to the formation of educational inequalities. Meanwhile, our knowledge about the role of ability in generating class differences in educational outcomes is still limited. By deploying genetic data that allow us to measure at least part of "innate" ability inherited through biological mechanisms from parents, this study examines how such abilities are associated with educational tracking outcomes among U.S. high schoolers. This study also details our understanding of the role of nature and nurture in the educational attainment processes by testing for gene-environment interactions-that is, a joint, mutually moderating effect of one's genetic potential and one's environment (e.g., family background or school context) on phenotypic outcomes (educational tracking). Using the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent to Adult Health that collects a unique set of demographic, educational, and genetic characteristics of students, we report the following results: First, a positive association between the genetic potential for educational attainment and taking advanced courses holds even after controlling for previous course tracking measures. Second, results provide suggestive evidence that parental SES amplifies the association between one's genetic potential for educational attainment and mathematics tracking. In contrast to the argument by some stratification scholars that places primary emphasis on the role of social background for the reproduction of educational stratification, the present findings imply that we need to fully consider the role of genetic inheritance for educational stratification in addition to social origin.
有大量证据表明,家庭背景和中等教育环境都对教育不平等的形成有影响。与此同时,我们对能力在导致教育成果的阶层差异中所起作用的了解仍然有限。通过运用基因数据,使我们能够测量至少部分通过生物机制从父母那里遗传而来的“先天”能力,本研究考察了这些能力与美国高中生教育分流结果之间的关联。本研究还通过测试基因 - 环境相互作用,即一个人的遗传潜力和其环境(如家庭背景或学校环境)对表型结果(教育分流)的联合、相互调节作用,详细阐述了我们对天性与教养在教育成就过程中作用的理解。利用全国青少年健康纵向研究,该研究收集了学生独特的人口统计学、教育和基因特征集,我们报告了以下结果:第一,即使在控制了先前的课程分流测量指标之后,教育成就的遗传潜力与修读高级课程之间仍存在正相关。第二,结果提供了暗示性证据,表明父母的社会经济地位放大了一个人的教育成就遗传潜力与数学分流之间的关联。与一些分层学者主要强调社会背景在教育分层再生产中的作用的观点不同,目前的研究结果意味着,除了社会出身之外,我们还需要充分考虑遗传继承在教育分层中的作用。