Li J Y, Li X M, Cui X D, Hu X Q, Yu P C, Sun G B
Department of Otorhinolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, Huashan Hospital of Fudan University, Shanghai 200040, China.
Zhonghua Er Bi Yan Hou Tou Jing Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2022 Feb 7;57(2):161-167. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.cn115330-20210415-00204.
To evaluate the effectiveness of mucosal flap combined with silicone keel for preventing and treating anterior commissure adhesion in canines and clinical cases. A prospective experiment was performed from November 2019 to June 2021. Twenty five canines were randomly divided into 5 groups(A, B, C, D, E). Group A, B, C, D received anterior commissure injury by CO laser, then separately treated with free mucosal flap-keel complex,intralaryngeal mucosal flap-keel complex, silicone keels and without treatment, group E didn't injure the vocal cord after intubation. The keel was removed after 2 weeks, the larynx was harvested after 4 weeks. The effectiveness of anterior commissure adhesion prevention was evaluated by manifestation under laryngoscope, standard vocal cord length and standard glottic area. A retrospective analysis was performed on sixteen patients with anterior commissure lesion, who underwent mucosal flap-keel technique in Huashan Hospital of Fudan University from January 2019 to January 2021 (10 cases with free mucosal flap-keel complex and 6 cases with intralaryngeal mucosal flap-keel complex). All the patients underwent evaluation of laryngeal function included manifestation under laryngoscope each month and voice analysis before and 3 month after surgery. SPSS 20.0 software was used for statistical analysis. No surgery accident or complication happened in canines and patients. The standard vocal cord length and standard glottic area after 4 weeks in group B were significantly higher than those in group A, C, D (=31.688, =16.444, <0.05). The standard vocal cord length and standard glottic area after 4 weeks in group A were also significantly higher than those in group C, D(=20.936, =11.786, <0.05). The standard vocal cord length and standard glottic area after 4 weeks in group A, B, E were not significantly different to that before surgery(=2.636, =2.582, =2.707, =2.673, =0.370, =0.821, =2.731, =2.753, =-0.529, >0.05). The standard vocal cord length and standard glottic area after 4 weeks in group C, D were significantly lower than those before surgery(=16.137, =13.984, =11.903, =14.587, =10.280, =22.974, <0.05). During 6-18 months of follow-up in clinical patients, no one developed a glottic web. Three months after surgery, Jitter, Shimmer, noise to harmonic ratio(NHR), the maximum phonation time(MPT)in all patients were significantly different from preoperative(=24.885, =22.643, =6.202, =-9.661, =25.459, =18.683, =5.705, =-20.840, <0.05). Mucosal flap combined with silicone keel is an effective technique for preventing and treating anterior commissure adhesion. The effect of pedicled intralaryngea lmucosal flap is better.
评估黏膜瓣联合硅胶支架预防和治疗犬类及临床病例前联合粘连的有效性。于2019年11月至2021年6月进行了一项前瞻性实验。将25只犬随机分为5组(A、B、C、D、E)。A、B、C、D组通过CO激光造成前联合损伤,然后分别接受游离黏膜瓣 - 支架复合体、喉内带蒂黏膜瓣 - 支架复合体、硅胶支架治疗及不治疗,E组插管后不损伤声带。2周后取出支架,4周后摘取喉部。通过喉镜下表现、标准声带长度和标准声门面积评估前联合粘连预防的有效性。对2019年1月至2021年1月在复旦大学附属华山医院接受黏膜瓣 - 支架技术治疗的16例前联合病变患者进行回顾性分析(10例游离黏膜瓣 - 支架复合体,6例喉内带蒂黏膜瓣 - 支架复合体)。所有患者均接受喉功能评估,包括每月喉镜下表现及手术前和手术后3个月的嗓音分析。使用SPSS 20.0软件进行统计分析。犬类和患者均未发生手术意外或并发症。B组4周后的标准声带长度和标准声门面积显著高于A、C、D组(F = 31.688,P = 16.444,P < 0.05)。A组4周后的标准声带长度和标准声门面积也显著高于C、D组(F = 20.936,P = 11.786,P < 0.05)。A、B、E组4周后的标准声带长度和标准声门面积与手术前无显著差异(F = 2.6三6,P = 2.582,P = 2.707,P = 2.673,P = 0.370,P = 0.821,F = 2.731,P = 2.753,P = -0.529,P > 0.05)。C、D组4周后的标准声带长度和标准声门面积显著低于手术前(F = 16.137,P = 13.984,F = 11.903,P = 14.587,P = 10.280,F = 22.974,P < 0.05)。临床患者随访6 - 18个月期间,无一例发生声门蹼。手术后3个月,所有患者的抖动、闪烁、噪声谐波比(NHR)、最长发声时间(MPT)与术前相比均有显著差异(F = 24.885,P = 22.643,F = 6.202,P = -9.661,F = 25.459,P = 18.683,F = 5.705,P = -20.840,P < 0.05)。黏膜瓣联合硅胶支架是预防和治疗前联合粘连的有效技术。喉内带蒂黏膜瓣的效果更好。