Institute of Sociological Research, University of Geneva, Geneva, Switzerland.
Department of Sociology, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Front Public Health. 2022 Feb 7;10:812776. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.812776. eCollection 2022.
This study revisits the effects of mammography screening programs on inequalities in breast screening uptake in Switzerland. The progressive introduction of regional mammography programs by 12 out of the 26 Swiss cantons (regions) since 1999 offers an opportunity to perform an ecological quasi-experimental study. We examine absolute income and marital status inequalities in mammography uptake, and whether the cantons' implementation of mammography programs moderate these inequalities, as previous research has devoted little attention to this. We use five waves of the Swiss Health Interview Survey covering the 1997-2017 period and comprising data on 14,267 women aged 50-70. Both up-to-date and ever-screening outcomes are analyzed with multilevel models which assess the mammography programs' within-canton effect. Findings show that higher income women and married women (compared to unmarried women) had significantly higher mammography uptake probabilities. Mammography programs did not moderate absolute income differences in up-to-date screening; however, they were associated with smaller absolute income differences in ever-screening uptake. Mammography programs related to higher screening uptake for married women, more than for unmarried women. In conclusion, we showed absolute income inequalities in mammography uptake which were not revealed by previous studies using relative inequality measures. Mammography programs may have contributed to reducing income inequalities in ever-screening, yet this was not observed for up-to-date screening. This study has implication for preventive health interventions-e.g., cancer screening promotion should pay attention to women's marital status since screening programs may widen the screening gap between married and unmarried women.
本研究重新探讨了乳腺筛查计划对瑞士乳腺筛查参与率不平等的影响。自 1999 年以来,26 个瑞士州(地区)中有 12 个州逐步推出了区域性乳腺 X 光筛查计划,这为进行生态准实验研究提供了机会。我们考察了乳腺 X 光检查参与率的绝对收入和婚姻状况不平等现象,以及各州实施乳腺 X 光检查计划是否会缓和这些不平等现象,因为之前的研究很少关注这一点。我们使用了瑞士健康访谈调查的五个波次的数据,涵盖了 1997 年至 2017 年期间的 14267 名年龄在 50-70 岁的女性。使用多层次模型分析了最新和以往筛查结果,该模型评估了乳腺 X 光检查计划在州内的效果。研究结果表明,收入较高的女性和已婚女性(与未婚女性相比)接受乳腺 X 光检查的概率明显更高。乳腺 X 光检查计划并没有缓和最新筛查中绝对收入差异;然而,它们与以往筛查中绝对收入差异的缩小有关。乳腺 X 光检查计划与已婚女性的筛查参与率增加有关,而与未婚女性的筛查参与率增加无关。总之,我们发现了之前使用相对不平等指标的研究中未揭示的乳腺 X 光检查参与率的绝对收入不平等现象。乳腺 X 光检查计划可能有助于减少以往筛查中的收入不平等,但在最新筛查中没有观察到这一点。本研究对预防性健康干预具有启示意义,例如,癌症筛查推广应该关注女性的婚姻状况,因为筛查计划可能会扩大已婚和未婚女性之间的筛查差距。