Prezioso Giovanni, Suppiej Agnese, Alberghini Valentina, Bergonzini Patrizia, Capra Maria Elena, Corsini Ilaria, De Fanti Alessandro, Fiumana Elisa, Fornaro Martina, Marangio Lucia, Ricciardelli Paolo, Serra Laura, Cordelli Duccio Maria, Esposito Susanna
Clinic of Pediatrics, Department of Medicine and Surgery, University Hospital of Parma, 43126 Parma, Italy.
Unit of Pediatrics, Sant'Anna University Hospital, 44124 Ferrara, Italy.
Life (Basel). 2022 Jan 19;12(2):142. doi: 10.3390/life12020142.
Headache is the most frequent neurological symptom in childhood and the main reason for admission to pediatric emergency departments. The aim of this consensus document is to define a shared clinical pathway between primary care pediatricians (PCP) and hospitals for the management of children presenting with headache. For the purposes of the study, a group of hospital pediatricians and a group of PCP from the Emilia Romagna's health districts were selected to achieve consensus using the RAND/UCLA appropriateness method. Thirty-nine clinical scenarios were developed: for each scenario, participants were asked to rank the appropriateness of each option from 1 to 9. Agreement was reached if ≥75% of participants ranked within the same range of appropriateness. The answers, results, and discussion helped to define the appropriateness of procedures with a low level of evidence regarding different steps of the diagnostic-therapeutic process: primary care evaluation, emergency department evaluation, hospital admission, acute therapy, prophylaxis, and follow-up. The RAND proved to be a valid method to value appropriateness of procedures and define a diagnostic-therapeutic pathway suitable to the local reality in the management of pediatric headache. From our results, some useful recommendations were developed for optimizing the healthcare professionals' network among primary care services and hospitals.
头痛是儿童期最常见的神经系统症状,也是儿童急诊就诊的主要原因。本共识文件的目的是确定基层儿科医生(PCP)和医院之间针对头痛患儿管理的共享临床路径。为了该研究,从艾米利亚 - 罗马涅大区卫生区挑选了一组医院儿科医生和一组基层儿科医生,采用兰德/加州大学洛杉矶分校适宜性方法达成共识。制定了39种临床场景:针对每种场景,要求参与者对每个选项的适宜性从1到9进行评分。如果≥75%的参与者在相同适宜性范围内评分,则达成共识。这些答案、结果和讨论有助于确定在诊断 - 治疗过程的不同步骤(基层医疗评估、急诊科评估、住院、急性治疗、预防和随访)中证据水平较低的程序的适宜性。兰德方法被证明是一种评估程序适宜性并确定适合当地实际情况的儿科头痛管理诊断 - 治疗路径的有效方法。根据我们的结果,制定了一些有用的建议,以优化基层医疗服务和医院之间的医疗专业人员网络。