Food and Drugs Authority, Accra, Ghana.
PharmacoTherapy, Epidemiology and Economics, Groningen Research Institute of Pharmacy, University of Groningen, Groningen, The Netherlands.
PLoS One. 2022 Mar 3;17(3):e0264699. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0264699. eCollection 2022.
Reviewing the epidemiological profile of medication errors (MEs) reported by African countries and the systems put in place to report such errors is crucial because reporting plays an important role in improving patient safety. The objectives of this study were to characterize the profile of spontaneously reported MEs submitted by African countries to VigiBase; the World Health Organization (WHO) global database of individual case safety reports, describe systems in place for reporting these errors, and explore the challenges and facilitators for spontaneous reporting and understand the potential role of patients.
In the present study, we used, a mixed-methods sequential explanatory design involving a quantitative review of ME reports over a 21-year period (1997-2018) and qualitative interviews with employees from African countries that are members of the WHO Program for International Drug Monitoring (WHO PIDM). Descriptive statistics were used to summarize key variables of interest.
A total of 4,205 ME reports were submitted by African countries to VigiBase representing 0.4% of all reports in the database. Only 15 countries out of the 37 WHO PIDM members from Africa contributed ME to reports, with 99% (3,874) of them reports originating from Egypt, Morocco, and South Africa. The reasons given for low reporting of MEs were weak healthcare and pharmacovigilance systems, lack of staff capacity at the national centers, illiteracy, language difficulties, and socio-cultural and religious beliefs. Some facilitators suggested by the participants to promote reporting included proactive engagement of patients regarding issues relating to MEs, leveraging on increased technology, benchmarking and mentoring by more experienced national centers. Sixteen of the twenty countries interviewed had systems for reporting MEs integrated into adverse drug reaction reporting with minimal patient involvement in seven of these countries. Patients were not involved in directly reporting MEs in the remaining 13 countries.
MEs are rarely reported through pharmacovigilance systems in African countries with limited patient involvement. The systems are influenced by multifactorial issues some of which are not directly related to healthcare.
审查非洲国家报告的药物错误(ME)的流行病学特征以及建立的报告系统至关重要,因为报告在提高患者安全性方面发挥着重要作用。本研究的目的是描述非洲国家向世界卫生组织(WHO)个体病例安全报告全球数据库 VigiBase 自发报告的 ME 特征;描述这些错误的报告系统,并探讨自发报告的挑战和促进因素,了解患者的潜在作用。
在本研究中,我们使用混合方法顺序解释设计,对 21 年来(1997-2018 年)的 ME 报告进行了定量审查,并对来自非洲的 WHO 药物监测国际计划(WHO PIDM)成员国的员工进行了定性访谈。使用描述性统计来总结感兴趣的关键变量。
非洲国家向 VigiBase 共提交了 4205 份 ME 报告,占数据库中所有报告的 0.4%。在来自非洲的 37 个 WHO PIDM 成员国中,只有 15 个国家向报告提交了 ME,其中 99%(3874 份)报告来自埃及、摩洛哥和南非。报告低报 ME 的原因是医疗保健和药物警戒系统薄弱、国家中心人员能力不足、文盲、语言困难以及社会文化和宗教信仰。参与者提出的一些促进报告的因素包括主动让患者参与与 ME 相关的问题、利用技术进步、通过更有经验的国家中心进行基准测试和指导。接受访谈的 20 个国家中有 16 个国家的 ME 报告系统与药物不良反应报告系统整合在一起,其中 7 个国家患者很少参与。在其余 13 个国家中,患者没有直接参与报告 ME。
在非洲国家,药物警戒系统很少报告 ME,且患者参与度有限。这些系统受到多方面因素的影响,其中一些因素与医疗保健无关。