Department of Public Health and Nursing, Norwegian University of Science and Technology (Ntnu), Trondheim, Norway.
Med Educ Online. 2022 Dec;27(1):2048514. doi: 10.1080/10872981.2022.2048514.
Clinical supervision is necessary to ensure students' learning and patient safety. There is limited research on how medical students' actions play into the dynamic of learning from clinical supervision. We aimed to explore undergraduate medical students' experiences with learning from clinical supervision, focusing on students' actions and interactions.
A qualitative study using semi-structured interviews with medical students at two English and four Norwegian universities. The main topics were students' experiences with clinical supervision, what students' felt helped them learn, and how they acted. Transcribed interviews were analysed thematically.
22 students participated. The actions participants described performing during supervision ranged from staying quiet to initiating active participation. They described that learning was more likely to take place when they took initiative, acted on opportunities to participate, and focused their attention on learning. When they did not feel safe, they were more likely to stay quietly in the background. When participants felt concerned for patients' welfare their attention shifted away from learning. While if they were appropriately confident, they engaged in learning.
Feelings of safety, patients' being cared for, and confidence impacted on students' actions and thus learning. Our findings suggest that when students feel psychologically safe, they are more likely to act and interact during clinical supervision. One way to improve psychological safety is to foster relationships between students and supervisors.
临床监督对于确保学生的学习和患者安全至关重要。关于医学生的行为如何影响从临床监督中学习的动态,相关研究有限。我们旨在探讨本科医学生从临床监督中学习的经验,重点关注学生的行为和互动。
这是一项使用半结构式访谈对来自两所英国和四所挪威大学的医学生进行的定性研究。主要主题是学生的临床监督经验、他们认为有助于学习的内容,以及他们的行为。对转录的访谈进行了主题分析。
共有 22 名学生参与。参与者描述的在监督期间执行的行为从保持安静到主动参与不等。他们描述说,当他们主动采取行动、利用参与机会并专注于学习时,学习更有可能发生。当他们感到不安全时,他们更有可能在后台保持安静。当参与者关心患者的福利时,他们的注意力就会从学习上转移开。而如果他们有适当的信心,他们就会参与学习。
安全感、患者得到照顾和信心会影响学生的行为,从而影响学习。我们的研究结果表明,当学生感到心理安全时,他们在临床监督期间更有可能采取行动和互动。提高心理安全感的一种方法是促进学生和导师之间的关系。