Hu Na, Zhang Tianwei, Wu Yifan, Tang Biqiu, Li Minlong, Song Bin, Gong Qiyong, Wu Min, Gu Shi, Lui Su
Department of Radiology, West China Hospital of Sichuan University, Chengdu, China.
Huaxi MR Research Center (HMRRC), Functional and Molecular Imaging Key Laboratory of Sichuan Province, Department of Radiology, West China Hospital of Sichuan University, Chengdu, China.
Ann Transl Med. 2022 Jan;10(2):35. doi: 10.21037/atm-21-4056.
Difficulties in detecting brain lesions in acute ischemic stroke (AIS) have convinced researchers to use computed tomography (CT) to scan for and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to search for these lesions. This work aimed to develop a generative adversarial network (GAN) model for CT-to-MR image synthesis and evaluate reader performance with synthetic MRI (syn-MRI) in detecting brain lesions in suspected patients.
Patients with primarily suspected AIS were randomly assigned to the training (n=140) or testing (n=53) set. Emergency CT and follow-up MR images in the training set were used to develop a GAN model to generate syn-MR images from the CT data in the testing set. The standard reference was the manual segmentations of follow-up MR images. Image similarity was evaluated between syn-MRI and the ground truth using a 4-grade visual rating scale, the peak signal-to-noise ratio (PSNR), and the structural similarity index measure (SSIM). Reader performance with syn-MRI and CT was evaluated and compared on a per-patient (patient detection) and per-lesion (lesion detection) basis. Paired -tests or Wilcoxon signed-rank tests were used to compare reader performance in lesion detection between the syn-MRI and CT data.
Grade 2-4 brain lesions were observed on syn-MRI in 92.5% (49/53) of the patients, while the remaining syn-MRI data showed no lesions compared to the ground truth. The GAN model exhibited a weak PSNR of 24.30 dB but a favorable SSIM of 0.857. Compared with CT, syn-MRI led to an increase in the overall sensitivity from 38% (57/150) to 82% (123/150) in patient detection and from 4% (68/1,620) to 16% (262/1,620) in lesion detection (R=0.32, corrected P<0.001), but the specificity in patient detection decreased from 67% (6/9) to 33% (3/9). An additional 75% (70/93) of patients and 15% (77/517) of lesions missed on CT were detected on syn-MRI.
The GAN model holds potential for generating synthetic MR images from noncontrast CT data and thus could help sensitively detect individuals among patients with suspected AIS. However, the image similarity performance of the model needs to be improved, and further expert discrimination is strongly recommended.
急性缺血性卒中(AIS)中脑病变检测存在困难,这促使研究人员使用计算机断层扫描(CT)来扫描以及磁共振成像(MRI)来寻找这些病变。这项工作旨在开发一种用于CT到MR图像合成的生成对抗网络(GAN)模型,并评估读者使用合成MRI(syn-MRI)检测疑似患者脑病变的性能。
主要疑似AIS的患者被随机分配到训练组(n = 140)或测试组(n = 53)。训练组中的急诊CT和随访MR图像用于开发GAN模型,以从测试组的CT数据生成syn-MR图像。标准参考是随访MR图像的手动分割。使用4级视觉评分量表、峰值信噪比(PSNR)和结构相似性指数测量(SSIM)评估syn-MRI与真实情况之间的图像相似性。在每位患者(患者检测)和每个病变(病变检测)的基础上评估并比较读者使用syn-MRI和CT的性能。使用配对t检验或Wilcoxon符号秩检验比较syn-MRI和CT数据在病变检测中读者的性能。
92.5%(49/53)的患者在syn-MRI上观察到2-4级脑病变,而其余syn-MRI数据与真实情况相比未显示病变。GAN模型的PSNR较弱,为24.30 dB,但SSIM良好,为0.857。与CT相比,syn-MRI在患者检测中的总体敏感性从38%(57/150)提高到82%(123/150),在病变检测中从4%(68/1,620)提高到16%(262/1,620)(R = 0.32,校正P<0.001),但患者检测中的特异性从67%(6/9)降至33%(3/9)。在syn-MRI上检测到另外75%(70/93)的患者和15%(77/517)在CT上漏诊的病变。
GAN模型具有从非增强CT数据生成合成MR图像的潜力,因此有助于在疑似AIS患者中敏感地检测个体。然而,该模型的图像相似性性能需要改进,强烈建议进一步进行专家鉴别。