Department of Radiology, Juntendo University School of Medicine, 1-2-1, Hongo, Bunkyo, Tokyo, 113-8421, Japan.
Department of Radiology, Graduate School of Medicine, The University of Tokyo, 7-3-1, Hongo, Bunkyo, Tokyo, 113-8654, Japan.
Eur Radiol. 2022 Jul;32(7):4791-4800. doi: 10.1007/s00330-022-08555-3. Epub 2022 Mar 18.
We aimed to investigate the influence of magnetic resonance fingerprinting (MRF) dictionary design on radiomic features using in vivo human brain scans.
Scan-rescans of three-dimensional MRF and conventional T1-weighted imaging were performed on 21 healthy volunteers (9 males and 12 females; mean age, 41.3 ± 14.6 years; age range, 22-72 years). Five patients with multiple sclerosis (3 males and 2 females; mean age, 41.2 ± 7.3 years; age range, 32-53 years) were also included. MRF data were reconstructed using various dictionaries with different step sizes. First- and second-order radiomic features were extracted from each dataset. Intra-dictionary repeatability and inter-dictionary reproducibility were evaluated using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs). Features with ICCs > 0.90 were considered acceptable. Relative changes were calculated to assess inter-dictionary biases.
The overall scan-rescan ICCs of MRF-based radiomics ranged from 0.86 to 0.95, depending on dictionary step size. No significant differences were observed in the overall scan-rescan repeatability of MRF-based radiomic features and conventional T1-weighted imaging (p = 1.00). Intra-dictionary repeatability was insensitive to dictionary step size differences. MRF-based radiomic features varied among dictionaries (overall ICC for inter-dictionary reproducibility, 0.62-0.99), especially when step sizes were large. First-order and gray level co-occurrence matrix features were the most reproducible feature classes among different step size dictionaries. T1 map-derived radiomic features provided higher repeatability and reproducibility among dictionaries than those obtained with T2 maps.
MRF-based radiomic features are highly repeatable in various dictionary step sizes. Caution is warranted when performing MRF-based radiomics using datasets containing maps generated from different dictionaries.
• MRF-based radiomic features are highly repeatable in various dictionary step sizes. • Use of different MRF dictionaries may result in variable radiomic features, even when the same MRF acquisition data are used. • Caution is needed when performing radiomic analysis using data reconstructed from different dictionaries.
本研究旨在通过对活体人脑扫描,探讨磁共振指纹图谱(MRF)字典设计对放射组学特征的影响。
对 21 名健康志愿者(9 名男性和 12 名女性;平均年龄 41.3±14.6 岁;年龄范围 22-72 岁)进行三维 MRF 和常规 T1 加权成像的扫描-重扫。还纳入了 5 名多发性硬化症患者(3 名男性和 2 名女性;平均年龄 41.2±7.3 岁;年龄范围 32-53 岁)。使用不同步长的各种字典重建 MRF 数据。从每个数据集提取一阶和二阶放射组学特征。使用组内相关系数(ICC)评估内字典重复性和外字典可重复性。ICC>0.90 的特征被认为是可接受的。计算相对变化以评估外字典偏差。
基于 MRF 的放射组学的整体扫描-重扫 ICC 范围为 0.86-0.95,具体取决于字典步长。基于 MRF 的放射组学特征和常规 T1 加权成像的整体扫描-重扫重复性无显著差异(p=1.00)。内字典重复性对外字典步长差异不敏感。基于 MRF 的放射组学特征在字典之间存在差异(外字典可重复性的整体 ICC 为 0.62-0.99),尤其是在步长较大时。一阶和灰度共生矩阵特征在不同步长大字典之间是最具可重复性的特征类别。基于 T1 图的放射组学特征在字典之间比基于 T2 图的放射组学特征具有更高的重复性和可重复性。
在各种字典步长下,基于 MRF 的放射组学特征具有高度可重复性。使用来自不同字典的数据集进行基于 MRF 的放射组学分析时需要谨慎。
基于 MRF 的放射组学特征在各种字典步长下具有高度可重复性。
即使使用相同的 MRF 采集数据,使用不同的 MRF 字典也可能导致放射组学特征发生变化。
使用来自不同字典的数据进行放射组学分析时需要谨慎。