Arief Irma Isnafia, Apriantini Astari, Jayanegara Anuraga, Budiman Cahyo
Department of Animal Production Science and Technology, Faculty of Animal Science, IPB University, Bogor 16680, Indonesia.
Department of Nutrition and Feed Science and Technology, Faculty of Animal Science, IPB University, Bogor 16680, Indonesia.
Food Sci Anim Resour. 2022 Mar;42(2):280-294. doi: 10.5851/kosfa.2022.e4. Epub 2022 Mar 1.
This study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of propolis extract as a natural preservative for livestock products in term of chemical and microbiological characteristics by meta-analysis. The stages carried out in this study were identification, selection, checking suitability, and the resulting selected articles were used in the meta-analysis. The selection results obtained a total of 22 selected journal articles consisting of 9 articles for analysis of the antimicrobial activity of propolis extract and 13 articles for analysis of the chemical and mirobiological characteristics of livestock products. The articles were obtained from electronic databases, namely Science Direct and Google Scholar. The model used in this study is the random-effect model involving two groups, control and experimental. Heterogeneity and effect size values were carried out in this study using Hedge's obtained through openMEE software. Forest plot tests and data validation on publication bias was obtained using Kendall's test throught JASP 0.14.1 software. The results showed that there is a significant relationship between propolis extract with the results of the antimicrobial activity (p<0.05). In addition, the results of the application of propolis extract on the livestock products for the test microbes and the value of thiobarbituric acid reactive substances (TBARs) showed significant results (p<0.05). Conclusion based on the random-effect model on the effectiveness of antimicrobial activity of propolis extract and their apllication as a natural preservative of the chemical and microbiological characteristics of livestock products is valid by Kendall's test (p>0.05). Propolis in this case effectively used as natural preservatives in livestock products.
本研究旨在通过荟萃分析,从化学和微生物学特性方面评估蜂胶提取物作为畜产品天然防腐剂的有效性。本研究进行的阶段包括识别、选择、检查适用性,所选文章用于荟萃分析。选择结果共获得22篇选定的期刊文章,其中9篇用于分析蜂胶提取物的抗菌活性,13篇用于分析畜产品的化学和微生物学特性。这些文章来自电子数据库,即科学Direct和谷歌学术。本研究使用的模型是涉及对照组和实验组的随机效应模型。本研究使用通过openMEE软件获得的Hedge's进行异质性和效应量值分析。使用JASP 0.14.1软件通过肯德尔检验获得森林图检验和发表偏倚的数据验证。结果表明,蜂胶提取物与抗菌活性结果之间存在显著关系(p<0.05)。此外,蜂胶提取物应用于畜产品对测试微生物和硫代巴比妥酸反应物质(TBARs)值的结果显示出显著结果(p<0.05)。基于随机效应模型对蜂胶提取物抗菌活性及其作为畜产品化学和微生物学特性天然防腐剂应用有效性的结论通过肯德尔检验有效(p>0.05)。在这种情况下,蜂胶可有效用作畜产品中的天然防腐剂。