Empa - Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, Technology and Society Laboratory, Lerchenfeldstrasse 5, CH-9014 St. Gallen, Switzerland.
Empa - Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, Technology and Society Laboratory, Lerchenfeldstrasse 5, CH-9014 St. Gallen, Switzerland.
Sci Total Environ. 2022 Jul 15;830:154655. doi: 10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.154655. Epub 2022 Mar 18.
Tire wear particle (TWP) emissions are gaining more attention since they are considered to contribute a major share to the overall microplastic emissions and are suspected to be harmful to flora, fauna and humans. Hence, recent studies derived country-based TWP emissions to better understand the significance of the problem using either tire emission factors (EF) or a material flow analysis (MFA) of tires. However, all 14 country-based TWP emission studies found and published since the year 2000 base their calculation on other studies rather than own measurements. Therefore, we started to search for the actual TWP measurements which the 14 studies would rely on. As a result, we found a network of 63 studies which were used to derive TWP emissions in different countries and regions. Only in few cases (12%) TWP emission studies reference directly to a measurement study to derive TWP emissions, but mostly (63%) they rely on reviews or summarizing studies. Additionally, we could not obtain 25 studies in the analysed network. In total we found nine studies which actually measured TWP emissions. Out of these four studies originate from the 1970s, one analysed only light vehicles and one only considered buses. Thus, only three non peer-reviewed studies were considered to show trustful results which were cited a maximum of three times in the network. The obtained 14 country-based studies suggest TWP emissions of about 1.3 kg capita year for the EF approach and 2.0 kg capita year for the MFA approach (overall range: 0.9-2.5 kg capita year). Consequently, we call for an urgent need to minimize uncertainties of TWP emission estimates to better understand the contribution of TWP to the overall microplastic pollution of the environment. A better understanding about quantities could also help to better address the risk of environmental pollution by TWP.
轮胎磨损颗粒(Tire Wear Particle,TWP)的排放引起了越来越多的关注,因为它们被认为是造成整体微塑料排放的主要原因之一,并且怀疑对植物、动物和人类有害。因此,最近的研究根据轮胎排放因子(Tire Emission Factors,EF)或轮胎的物质流分析(Material Flow Analysis,MFA),推导出了基于国家的 TWP 排放量,以便更好地理解这个问题的重要性。然而,自 2000 年以来,所有 14 项基于国家的 TWP 排放研究都是基于其他研究而不是自己的测量结果来进行计算的。因此,我们开始寻找这 14 项研究所依赖的实际 TWP 测量结果。结果,我们发现了一个由 63 项研究组成的网络,这些研究用于推导不同国家和地区的 TWP 排放量。只有在少数情况下(12%),TWP 排放研究直接参考测量研究来推导 TWP 排放,但大多数情况下(63%)是基于综述或总结研究。此外,我们无法在分析网络中获得 25 项研究。在总共发现的研究中,有九项实际上测量了 TWP 排放。其中四项研究来自 20 世纪 70 年代,一项仅分析了轻型车辆,一项仅考虑了公共汽车。因此,只有三项非同行评议的研究被认为是可靠的,它们在网络中最多被引用了三次。这些基于国家的研究表明,EF 方法的 TWP 排放量约为每人每年 1.3 公斤,MFA 方法的 TWP 排放量约为每人每年 2.0 公斤(总体范围为每人每年 0.9-2.5 公斤)。因此,我们呼吁迫切需要减少 TWP 排放估计的不确定性,以更好地了解 TWP 对环境中整体微塑料污染的贡献。对数量的更好理解也有助于更好地解决 TWP 对环境污染的风险。