IEEE Trans Neural Syst Rehabil Eng. 2022;30:869-877. doi: 10.1109/TNSRE.2022.3162213. Epub 2022 Apr 6.
Robotic ankle exoskeletons have the potential to extend human ability, and actuation timing serves as one of the critical parameters in its controller design. While many experiments have investigated the optimal actuation timing values to achieve different objective functions (e.g. minimizing metabolic cost), studies on users' perception of control parameters are gaining interest as it gives information on people's comfort, coordination, and trust in using devices, as well as providing foundations on how the sensorimotor system detects the exoskeleton behavior changes. The purpose of this study was to evaluate people's sensitivity to changes in exoskeleton actuation timing and its associated exoskeleton ankle angle changes during walking. Participants (n =15) with little or no prior experience with ankle exoskeletons were recruited and performed a psychophysical experiment to characterize their just-noticeable difference (JND) thresholds for actuation timing. Participants wore a bilateral active ankle exoskeleton and compared pairs of torque profiles with different actuation timings and low peak torque (0.225 Nm/kg) while walking on the treadmill. The mean timing JND across participants was 2.8±0.6% stride period. Individuals exhibited different sensitivity towards actuation timing, and their associated exoskeleton ankle angle changes also varied. The variance in ankle angle changes might be explained by their differences in ankle stiffness and different ankle torques provided during walking. The results provide insights into how people perceive the changes in exoskeleton control parameters and show individual differences in exoskeleton usage. The actuation timing JND found in this study can also help determine the necessary controller precision.
机器人踝关节外骨骼有潜力扩展人类的能力,而作动时间是其控制器设计的关键参数之一。虽然许多实验已经研究了实现不同目标函数(例如最小化代谢成本)的最佳作动时间值,但对用户对控制参数的感知的研究越来越受到关注,因为它提供了有关人们在使用设备时的舒适度、协调性和信任的信息,以及关于感觉运动系统如何检测外骨骼行为变化的基础。本研究的目的是评估人们对行走时外骨骼作动时间及其相关踝关节角度变化的敏感性。招募了一些几乎没有或没有踝关节外骨骼使用经验的参与者,并进行了一项心理物理学实验,以确定他们对作动时间的可察觉差异 (JND) 阈值。参与者穿着双侧主动踝关节外骨骼,在跑步机上行走时比较了具有不同作动时间和低峰值扭矩(0.225 Nm/kg)的扭矩曲线对。参与者的平均作动时间 JND 为 2.8±0.6%步幅周期。个体对作动时间表现出不同的敏感性,并且它们相关的外骨骼踝关节角度变化也不同。踝关节角度变化的差异可能可以用他们在行走时的踝关节刚度和提供的不同踝关节扭矩来解释。研究结果深入了解了人们如何感知外骨骼控制参数的变化,并展示了外骨骼使用方面的个体差异。本研究中发现的作动时间 JND 也有助于确定必要的控制器精度。