Souto Ferreira Leonardo, Canton Otavio, da Silva Rafael Lopes Paixão, Poloni Silas, Sudbrack Vítor, Borges Marcelo Eduardo, Franco Caroline, Marquitti Flavia Maria Darcie, de Moraes José Cássio, Veras Maria Amélia de Sousa Mascena, Kraenkel Roberto André, Coutinho Renato Mendes
Instituto de Física Teórica, Universidade Estadual Paulista, São Paulo, Brazil.
Observatório COVID-19 BR, São Paulo, Brazil.
PLoS Comput Biol. 2022 Mar 25;18(3):e1009978. doi: 10.1371/journal.pcbi.1009978. eCollection 2022 Mar.
The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic is a major concern all over the world and, as vaccines became available at the end of 2020, optimal vaccination strategies were subjected to intense investigation. Considering their critical role in reducing disease burden, the increasing demand outpacing production, and that most currently approved vaccines follow a two-dose regimen, the cost-effectiveness of delaying the second dose to increment the coverage of the population receiving the first dose is often debated. Finding the best solution is complex due to the trade-off between vaccinating more people with lower level of protection and guaranteeing higher protection to a fewer number of individuals. Here we present a novel extended age-structured SEIR mathematical model that includes a two-dose vaccination schedule with a between-doses delay modelled through delay differential equations and linear optimization of vaccination rates. By maintaining the minimum stock of vaccines under a given production rate, we evaluate the dose interval that minimizes the number of deaths. We found that the best strategy depends on an interplay between the vaccine production rate and the relative efficacy of the first dose. In the scenario of low first-dose efficacy, it is always better to vaccinate the second dose as soon as possible, while for high first-dose efficacy, the best strategy of time window depends on the production rate and also on second-dose efficacy provided by each type of vaccine. We also found that the rate of spread of the infection does not affect significantly the thresholds of the best window, but is an important factor in the absolute number of total deaths. These conclusions point to the need to carefully take into account both vaccine characteristics and roll-out speed to optimize the outcome of vaccination strategies.
严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒2(SARS-CoV-2)大流行是全球主要关切的问题,随着2020年底疫苗可用,最佳疫苗接种策略受到了深入研究。考虑到疫苗在减轻疾病负担方面的关键作用、需求增长超过产量,以及目前大多数获批疫苗采用两剂接种方案,推迟第二剂接种以增加接受第一剂接种人群的覆盖率的成本效益经常受到争论。由于在以较低保护水平接种更多人和为较少个体提供更高保护之间进行权衡,找到最佳解决方案很复杂。在此,我们提出了一种新颖的扩展年龄结构的易感-暴露-感染-康复(SEIR)数学模型,该模型包括一个两剂接种计划,通过延迟微分方程对剂次间隔进行建模,并对接种率进行线性优化。通过在给定生产率下维持疫苗的最低库存,我们评估使死亡人数最少的剂次间隔。我们发现,最佳策略取决于疫苗生产率和第一剂的相对效力之间的相互作用。在第一剂效力较低的情况下,尽早接种第二剂总是更好的选择,而对于第一剂效力较高的情况,最佳时间窗口策略取决于生产率以及每种疫苗提供的第二剂效力。我们还发现,感染传播率对最佳窗口阈值没有显著影响,但对总死亡绝对数是一个重要因素。这些结论表明,需要仔细考虑疫苗特性和推出速度,以优化疫苗接种策略的结果。