Vendl Catharina, Pottier Patrice, Taylor Matthew D, Bräunig Jennifer, Gibson Matthew J, Hesselson Daniel, Neely G Gregory, Lagisz Malgorzata, Nakagawa Shinichi
Evolution and Ecology Research Centre and School of Biology Earth & Environmental Sciences, University of New South Wales Sydney, Sydney, NSW, 2052, Australia.
Evolution and Ecology Research Centre and School of Biology Earth & Environmental Sciences, University of New South Wales Sydney, Sydney, NSW, 2052, Australia.
Environ Pollut. 2022 Jul 1;304:119081. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol.2022.119081. Epub 2022 Mar 30.
Per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) are ubiquitous in the environment and often ingested with food. PFAS exposure in people can have detrimental health consequences. Therefore, reducing PFAS burdens in food items is of great importance to public health. Here, we investigated whether cooking reduces PFAS concentrations in animal-derived food products by synthesizing experimental studies. Further, we examined the moderating effects of the following five variables: cooking time, liquid/animal tissue ratio, cooking temperature, carbon chain length of PFAS and the cooking category (oil-based, water-based & no-liquid cooking). In our systematic review searches, we obtained 512 effect sizes (relative differences in PFAS concentration between raw and cooked samples) from 10 relevant studies. These studies exclusively explored changes in PFAS concentrations in cooked seafood and freshwater fish. Our multilevel-meta-analysis has revealed that, on average, cooking reduced PFAS concentrations by 29%, although heterogeneity among effect sizes was very high (I = 94.65%). Our five moderators cumulatively explained 49% of the observed heterogeneity. Specifically, an increase in cooking time and liquid/animal tissue ratio, as well as shorter carbon chain length of PFAS (when cooked with oil) were associated with significant reductions in PFAS concentrations. The effects of different ways of cooking depended on the other moderators, while the effect of cooking temperature itself was not significant. Overall, cooking can reduce PFAS concentrations in blue food (seafood and freshwater fish). However, it is important to note that complete PFAS elimination requires unrealistically long cooking times and large liquid/animal tissue ratios. Currently, literature on the impact of cooking of terrestrial animal produce on PFAS concentrations is lacking, which limits the inference and generalisation of our meta-analysis. However, our work represents the first step towards developing guidelines to reduce PFAS in food via cooking exclusively with common kitchen items and techniques.
全氟和多氟烷基物质(PFAS)在环境中无处不在,且常随食物摄入人体。人体接触PFAS会对健康产生有害影响。因此,降低食品中的PFAS含量对公众健康至关重要。在此,我们通过综合实验研究来探究烹饪是否会降低动物源食品中的PFAS浓度。此外,我们还考察了以下五个变量的调节作用:烹饪时间、液体/动物组织比例、烹饪温度、PFAS的碳链长度以及烹饪类别(油基、水基和无液体烹饪)。在我们的系统综述检索中,我们从10项相关研究中获得了512个效应量(生熟样品中PFAS浓度的相对差异)。这些研究仅探讨了烹饪后海鲜和淡水鱼中PFAS浓度的变化。我们的多水平荟萃分析表明,平均而言,烹饪使PFAS浓度降低了29%,尽管效应量之间的异质性非常高(I² = 94.65%)。我们的五个调节变量累计解释了观察到的异质性的49%。具体而言,烹饪时间和液体/动物组织比例的增加,以及PFAS碳链长度较短(油煮时)与PFAS浓度的显著降低有关。不同烹饪方式的效果取决于其他调节变量,而烹饪温度本身的影响并不显著。总体而言,烹饪可以降低蓝色食物(海鲜和淡水鱼)中的PFAS浓度。然而,需要注意的是,要完全消除PFAS需要极长的烹饪时间和极大的液体/动物组织比例,这并不现实。目前,缺乏关于陆地动物产品烹饪对PFAS浓度影响的文献,这限制了我们荟萃分析的推断和推广。不过,我们的工作是朝着制定指南迈出的第一步,该指南旨在仅通过常见的厨房用品和技术烹饪来降低食品中的PFAS含量。