School of Public Health, University of Alberta, 4-308 Edmonton Clinic Health Academy, 11405-87 Avenue, Edmonton, AB, T6G 1C9, Canada.
School of Public Health, University of Alberta, 8303-112 Street, Edmonton, AB, T6G 2T4, Canada.
BMC Public Health. 2022 Apr 6;22(1):665. doi: 10.1186/s12889-022-13030-1.
Citizen science bears potential to build a comprehensive view of global food environments and create a broader discussion about how to improve them. Despite its potential, citizen science has not been fully utilised in food environment research. Thus, we sought to explore stakeholders' experiences of the Local Environment Action on Food (LEAF) project, a community-based intervention that employs a citizen science approach to monitoring food environments.
We used a qualitative collective case study design to explore citizen science through the LEAF process in seven communities in Alberta, Canada. Data generating strategies included semi-structured interviews with citizen scientists (n = 26), document review of communities' Mini Nutrition Report Cards (n = 7), and researcher observation. Data were analyzed in a multi-phase process, using Charmaz's constant comparison analysis strategy.
Analysis revealed two main themes: relationship building and process factors. Communities used three interconnected strategies, engaging the right people, treading lightly, and reaching a consensus, to navigate the vital but challenging relationship building process. Process factors, which were influences on the LEAF process and relationship building, included the local context, flexibility in the LEAF process, and turnover among LEAF community groups.
Citizen science through the LEAF project supported the creation and application of food environment evidence: it enabled residents to collect and interpret local food environment data, develop realistic recommendations for change, and provided them with an evidence-based advocacy tool to support the implementation of these recommendations. We recommend a web application that enables independent community food environment assessments. Such a tool could stimulate and sustain citizen involvement in food environment efforts, helping to build the necessary evidence base and promote the creation of healthy food environments.
公民科学有可能构建全球食品环境的综合视图,并就如何改善食品环境展开更广泛的讨论。尽管具有潜力,但公民科学在食品环境研究中尚未得到充分利用。因此,我们试图探讨利益相关者对基于社区的干预项目“食品地方环境行动”(LEAF)的经验,该项目采用公民科学方法监测食品环境。
我们使用定性的集体案例研究设计,通过加拿大艾伯塔省的七个社区的 LEAF 流程探索公民科学。生成数据的策略包括对公民科学家(n=26)进行半结构化访谈、对社区的迷你营养报告卡(n=7)进行文件审查以及研究者观察。使用 Charmaz 的恒比分析策略在多阶段过程中分析数据。
分析揭示了两个主要主题:关系建设和过程因素。社区使用了三种相互关联的策略,即吸引合适的人、谨慎行事和达成共识,以应对关键但具有挑战性的关系建设过程。对 LEAF 过程和关系建设产生影响的过程因素包括当地背景、LEAF 流程的灵活性以及 LEAF 社区群体的人员流动。
通过 LEAF 项目开展的公民科学支持了食品环境证据的创建和应用:它使居民能够收集和解释当地食品环境数据,为变革制定现实可行的建议,并为他们提供基于证据的倡导工具,以支持这些建议的实施。我们建议开发一个能够进行独立社区食品环境评估的网络应用程序。这样的工具可以激发和维持公民对食品环境工作的参与,有助于构建必要的证据基础并促进健康食品环境的创建。