Nursing College, Department of Community Health Nursing, Taibah University, Medina, Saudi Arabia.
College of Applied Medical Science, Nursing Department, Bisha University, Bisha, Saudi Arabia.
Int Nurs Rev. 2022 Dec;69(4):492-502. doi: 10.1111/inr.12755. Epub 2022 Apr 9.
To summarize the findings from literature regarding the prevalence of plagiarism and its various types, knowledge, and attitudes of students toward plagiarism, factors associated with plagiarism, and the applied interventions to decrease the incidence of plagiarism.
Plagiarism is a major form of academic dishonesty practiced by students at all educational levels.
Academic dishonesty was defined as any unauthorized help that adds to students' formal academic performance. These dishonest behaviors can be categorized as falsifying information, hiding errors, collaborating with colleagues when not allowed, and plagiarism.
Systematic search of databases was conducted in September 2021 to identify studies that discussed plagiarism in nursing studies. We included 31 studies in this systematic review and meta-analysis, with a total of 9,175 nursing students. The analysis was conducted using RevMan software.
Plagiarism was the most frequent academic misconduct among nursing students (practiced by 55.3%). Paraphrasing without referencing was the most practiced form (39.53%), while submitting others' work without acknowledgment was the least one (9.61%). Most students were aware of the concept of plagiarism (80.8%) and had positive ethical attitudes toward it (88.26%). Plagiarism was negatively associated with age, parenting, and completing semester credits. However, it was positively correlated with average grades and liberal educators. Plagiarism was a significant predictor of clinical misconduct.
A gap in the students' knowledge and skills were noticed. These gaps may be contributing to the high occurrence of plagiaristic acts, besides the unethical attitudes.
Plagiarism is a serious academic misconduct practice that can be associated with subsequent clinical misconduct. There is a need to fill the knowledge and skills gap, and to set effective policies.
In their attempts to eliminate plagiarism, nurse educators are encouraged to provide effective educational training and practical tasks, in order to fill the gaps in knowledge and skills. Additionally, implementing clear and effective punishment policies would prevent intentional plagiaristic acts. This would aid in introducing qualified nurses accountable for the health of patients.
总结文献中关于剽窃的普遍性及其各种类型、学生对剽窃的认知和态度、与剽窃相关的因素以及减少剽窃发生率的应用干预措施的发现。
剽窃是学生在所有教育层次上实施的主要学术不诚实形式。
学术不诚实被定义为任何未经授权的帮助,可增加学生的正式学术表现。这些不诚实的行为可以分为伪造信息、隐瞒错误、在不允许的情况下与同事合作以及剽窃。
2021 年 9 月,我们对数据库进行了系统检索,以确定讨论护理研究中剽窃的研究。我们对 31 项研究进行了系统综述和荟萃分析,共有 9175 名护理学生。分析使用 RevMan 软件进行。
剽窃是护理学生中最常见的学术不当行为(占 55.3%)。没有引用的改写是最常见的形式(39.53%),而不承认提交他人的作品是最不常见的形式(9.61%)。大多数学生都了解剽窃的概念(80.8%),对其持积极的道德态度(88.26%)。剽窃与年龄、父母教养方式和完成学期学分呈负相关,但与平均成绩和自由教育者呈正相关。剽窃是临床不当行为的一个重要预测因素。
学生的知识和技能存在差距。这些差距可能除了不道德的态度外,也是剽窃行为高发的原因。
剽窃是一种严重的学术不端行为,可能与随后的临床不当行为有关。有必要填补知识和技能的差距,并制定有效的政策。
鼓励护理教育者在努力消除剽窃时提供有效的教育培训和实践任务,以填补知识和技能的差距。此外,实施明确和有效的惩罚政策将防止故意剽窃行为。这将有助于引入对患者健康负责的合格护士。