Department of Music, Steinhardt School of Culture, Education, and Human Development, New York University, New York, NY, United States.
Front Neurosci. 2022 Mar 17;16:808038. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2022.808038. eCollection 2022.
The integrative powers of human auditory perception in masterful performing artists can create nuances of sound from the interpretation of notes on a written page that often seem beyond one's grasp as a listener. It is important to consider what type of feedback can provide a clearer understanding of nuances in sound to guide motor learning for the acquisition of new skills for expression. Master pianists' performance has been used as a model for imitation. However, to ensure the accuracy of imitation and clear understanding, sonification was examined for its effectiveness in providing a more immediate understanding of individual interpretations in terms of inter-onset timing and velocity of the notes. Three master concert pianists volunteered to record a performance of the Chopin Nocturne Opus 15 No. 1 on a Yamaha Disklavier Pro MIDI (music instrument digital interface) grand piano. Logic software was used to analyze and compare MIDI data from each performance from the perspective of phrase-by-phrase, note onset timings, and corresponding data from the other pianists. The study objectives were to examine commonalities and differences in timing and dynamics among the performances using MIDI measurements; to probe whether listening to comparative performance data assisted with feedback from sonification would enhance music students' understanding of the interpretive nuances through imitation; and to determine whether auditory-assisted sonification feedback could be used as a tool to expand students' interpretive choices and enhance performance. Participants imitated selected phrases of each of the master pianists, first with only music listening, and then with feedback from the sonified, comparative performance data. Results showed limited success in attempts to imitate the model with auditory feedback alone. Auditory-assisted sonification feedback significantly enhanced the participants' abilities to imitate the model faster and with greater accuracy in the final imitation experiments. The data gathered by the study provide insights on this kind of sonification as an effective feedback tool for heightening participants' auditory understanding of nuances in sound, as well as providing an effective teaching tool for imitation exercises.
技艺精湛的表演艺术家所具备的人类听觉感知综合能力,能够从书面乐谱上的音符诠释中创造出声音的细微差别,而作为听众往往难以领会这些差别。思考何种类型的反馈能够更清晰地理解声音中的细微差别,从而指导运动学习以获取新的表达技能,这一点很重要。大师级钢琴家的演奏一直被用作模仿的典范。然而,为确保模仿的准确性和清晰理解,研究了声化在依据音符的起始间隔时间和速度提供对个人诠释更直接理解方面的有效性。三位音乐会钢琴大师自愿在一台雅马哈Disklavier Pro MIDI(乐器数字接口)三角钢琴上录制肖邦《夜曲》作品15之1的演奏。使用Logic软件从逐乐句、音符起始时间以及其他钢琴家的相应数据角度分析和比较每次演奏的MIDI数据。研究目标包括:使用MIDI测量来检验演奏之间在时间和力度方面的共性与差异;探究聆听比较性演奏数据并辅以声化反馈是否会通过模仿增强音乐专业学生对诠释细微差别的理解;以及确定听觉辅助的声化反馈是否可作为一种工具来扩展学生的诠释选择并提升演奏水平。参与者模仿每位大师钢琴家的选定乐句,先是仅通过聆听音乐,然后是在声化的比较性演奏数据反馈的情况下进行模仿。结果表明,仅靠听觉反馈模仿典范的尝试成效有限。在最后的模仿实验中,听觉辅助的声化反馈显著提高了参与者更快、更准确地模仿典范的能力。该研究收集的数据为这种声化作为一种有效的反馈工具提供了见解,有助于增强参与者对声音细微差别的听觉理解,同时也为模仿练习提供了一种有效的教学工具。