Fausor Rocío, Sanz Jesús, Navarro-McCarthy Ashley, Gesteira Clara, Morán Noelia, Cobos-Redondo Beatriz, Altungy Pedro, Marqueses José M S, Sanz-García Ana, García-Vera María P
Departamento de Personalidad, Evaluación y Psicología Clínica, Facultad de Psicología, Universidad Complutense de Madrid, Madrid, Spain.
Front Psychol. 2022 Mar 23;13:847099. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.847099. eCollection 2022.
Scientific literature on posttraumatic growth (PTG) after terrorist attacks has primarily focused on persons who had not been directly exposed to terrorist attacks or persons who had been directly exposed to them, but who were assessed few months or years after the attacks.
We examined long-term PTG in 210 adults directly exposed to terrorist attacks in Spain a mean of 29.6 years after the attacks (range: 2-47 years). The participants had been injured by a terrorist attack (38.6%) or were first-degree relatives of people who had been killed or injured by a terrorist attack (41.4% and 20%, respectively). They completed diagnostic measures of emotional disorders and measures of PTSD and depression symptomatology, optimism, and PTG.
Multiple regression analyses revealed gender differences (women reported higher levels of PTG than did men) and a positive linear relationship between PTG and cumulative trauma after the terrorist attack. Some PTG dimensions were significantly associated with PTSD symptomatology, these associations being linear, not curvilinear. However, PTG was not associated with depression symptomatology, diagnosis of emotional disorders, age, elapsed time since the attack, or optimism. In comparison with survivors assessed 18 years after the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing, Spanish victims of terrorism showed higher levels of appreciation of life, but lower levels of relating to others and spiritual change.
The findings underscore the influence of gender on PTG and provide support to the hypothesis that some emotional distress may be a necessary condition of PTG. Future studies on PTG after terrorist attacks should take into consideration the characteristics of the terrorist attack itself and the contexts of violence and threat in which it occurred. The political, social, and cultural characteristics of the community affected by it and the profile and characteristics of other traumatic events suffered after the attack should also be taken into account in further research.
关于恐怖袭击后创伤后成长(PTG)的科学文献主要集中在未直接遭受恐怖袭击的人群,或虽直接遭受袭击但在袭击发生数月或数年之后接受评估的人群。
我们对210名在西班牙直接遭受恐怖袭击的成年人进行了长期PTG研究,袭击发生后的平均时间为29.6年(范围:2 - 47年)。参与者曾因恐怖袭击而受伤(38.6%),或是恐怖袭击遇难或受伤者的一级亲属(分别为41.4%和20%)。他们完成了情绪障碍的诊断测量以及创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)、抑郁症状、乐观主义和PTG的测量。
多元回归分析揭示了性别差异(女性报告的PTG水平高于男性)以及PTG与恐怖袭击后的累积创伤之间存在正线性关系。PTG的某些维度与PTSD症状显著相关,这些关联是线性的,而非曲线的。然而,PTG与抑郁症状、情绪障碍诊断、年龄、袭击发生后的时间间隔或乐观主义无关。与1995年俄克拉荷马城爆炸案18年后评估的幸存者相比,西班牙恐怖主义受害者对生活的感激程度更高,但在与他人的关系及精神变化方面的水平较低。
研究结果强调了性别对PTG的影响,并支持了以下假设:一些情绪困扰可能是PTG的必要条件。未来关于恐怖袭击后PTG的研究应考虑恐怖袭击本身的特征以及其发生的暴力和威胁背景。受其影响的社区的政治、社会和文化特征以及袭击后遭受的其他创伤事件的概况和特征在进一步研究中也应予以考虑。