McCarthy P L, Lembo R M, Fink H D, Baron M A, Cicchetti D V
J Pediatr. 1987 Jan;110(1):26-30. doi: 10.1016/s0022-3476(87)80282-2.
To determine if observational assessment performed in a systematic manner adds to the efficacy of the traditional history and physical examination in detecting serious illnesses in febrile children, and to determine the sensitivity of the combined evaluation, we studied consecutive patients less than or equal to 24 months of age seen for evaluation of fever at the Primary Care Center-Emergency Room (PCC-ER) of the Yale-New Haven Hospital (n = 143) and a suburban private practice (n = 207). An attending pediatrician performed the observation using the previously reported Acute Illness Observation Scales (AIOS). Subsequently, the history and physical examination were done by an attending pediatrician, and findings were scored as to whether they suggested the presence of a serious illness. Thirty-six patients, 28 in the PCC-ER and eight in the private practice, had a serious illness. The combined AIOS, history, and physical examination had a higher sensitivity and r correlation for serious illness than did the traditional history and physical examination. Three children with serious illnesses, all of whom had no abnormalities on history and physical examination, were identified only by use of AIOS. We conclude that assessment of appearance in a child with fever, when performed in a careful, integrated, stepwise fashion, improves the sensitivity of the history and physical examination in detecting serious illnesses in febrile children.
为了确定系统进行的观察性评估是否能提高传统病史和体格检查在检测发热儿童严重疾病方面的功效,并确定联合评估的敏感性,我们对耶鲁 - 纽黑文医院初级保健中心急诊室(PCC - ER)(n = 143)和一家郊区私人诊所(n = 207)中因发热前来评估的连续年龄小于或等于24个月的患者进行了研究。一名主治儿科医生使用先前报道的急性疾病观察量表(AIOS)进行观察。随后,由一名主治儿科医生进行病史采集和体格检查,并根据检查结果是否提示存在严重疾病进行评分。36名患者患有严重疾病,其中28名在PCC - ER,8名在私人诊所。与传统病史和体格检查相比,联合AIOS、病史和体格检查对严重疾病具有更高的敏感性和相关性。3名患有严重疾病的儿童,其病史和体格检查均无异常,仅通过AIOS才被识别出来。我们得出结论,对发热儿童的外观进行仔细、综合、逐步的评估,可提高病史和体格检查在检测发热儿童严重疾病方面的敏感性。