International Food Policy Research Institute, Washington DC, USA.
Food Nutr Bull. 2022 Sep;43(3):364-375. doi: 10.1177/03795721221090380. Epub 2022 Apr 19.
Little is known about the sustained effects of nutrition- and gender-sensitive agricultural programs (NSAPs) after they end.
To examine the 4-year effects (2010-2014) of a 2-year NSAP (2010-2012) on women's outcomes in rural Burkina Faso.
We used baseline (2010) and endline (2012) data from a cluster-randomized controlled trial of Helen Keller International's Enhanced Homestead Food Production (EHFP) program and baseline (2014) data from a new program. We included 134 women: 82 who participated in the 2-year EHFP program (treatment) and 52 who did not (control). We examined program (2010-2012), post-program (2012-2014), and overall 4-year effects (2010-2014) using difference-in-difference analysis (DID).
We found significant positive program effects (2010-2012) on women's underweight prevalence (DID: 16.44 percentage points [pp]; .09) and on women's knowledge about appropriate age to introduce liquids (DID: 28.40 pp; = .01). Although there were no significant postprogram effects (2012-2014), differences found in 2012 between the treatment and control group were sustained resulting in an overall 4-year (2010-2014) reduction in women's underweight prevalence (DID: 18.26 pp; = .02) and an improvement in women's knowledge about appropriate age to introduce liquids (DID: 31.29 pp; = .02). We observed no postprogram or overall 4-year effects on women's knowledge of child feeding and handwashing practices or women's empowerment.
Nutrition- and gender-sensitive agricultural programs demonstrate potential for sustained improvements in women's nutritional status and nutritional knowledge. Postprogram assessments of NSAPs should be embedded in program evaluations to help further understand the potential of NSAPs to generate sustainable impacts on women's outcomes.
人们对营养和性别敏感型农业计划(NSAP)结束后的持续效果知之甚少。
研究一项为期 2 年的 NSAP(2010-2012 年)对布基纳法索农村地区妇女结局的 4 年影响(2010-2014 年)。
我们使用海伦·凯勒国际组织增强家庭粮食生产计划(EHFP)的一项基于群组的随机对照试验的基线(2010 年)和终线(2012 年)数据,以及一项新计划的基线(2014 年)数据。我们纳入了 134 名妇女:82 名参加了为期 2 年的 EHFP 计划(治疗组),52 名未参加(对照组)。我们使用差分分析(DID),分别考察了计划(2010-2012 年)、计划后(2012-2014 年)和 4 年总体(2010-2014 年)效果。
我们发现,妇女体重不足的发生率(DID:16.44 个百分点[pp];.09)和妇女关于适当引入液体的年龄知识(DID:28.40 pp; =.01)等方面出现了显著的正向计划效果(2010-2012 年)。尽管没有明显的计划后效果(2012-2014 年),但 2012 年治疗组和对照组之间的差异仍在持续,导致妇女体重不足的发生率在 4 年总体期间(2010-2014 年)有所下降(DID:18.26 pp; =.02),妇女关于适当引入液体的年龄知识有所改善(DID:31.29 pp; =.02)。我们没有观察到计划后或 4 年总体对妇女的儿童喂养和洗手实践知识或妇女赋权的影响。
营养和性别敏感型农业计划显示出在妇女营养状况和营养知识方面持续改善的潜力。NSAP 的计划后评估应嵌入到方案评估中,以帮助进一步了解 NSAP 产生对妇女成果的可持续影响的潜力。