Faculty of Health, University of Technology Sydney, Ultimo, Australia.
Faculty of Medicine and Health, University of Sydney, Camperdown, Australia.
Health Res Policy Syst. 2022 Apr 20;20(1):44. doi: 10.1186/s12961-022-00845-y.
Effective integration of evidence and youth perspectives into policy is crucial for supporting the future health and well-being of young people. The aim of this project was to translate evidence from the Access 3 project to support development of a new state policy on youth health and well-being within New South Wales (NSW), Australia. Ensuring the active contribution of young people within policy development was a key objective of the knowledge translation (KT) process.
The KT activity consisted of a 1-day facilitated forum with 64 purposively sampled stakeholders. Participants included eight young people, 14 policy-makers, 15 academics, 22 clinicians or managers from NSW health services, four general practitioners and one mental health service worker. Research to be translated came from the synthesized findings of the NSW Access 3 project. The design of the forum included stakeholder presentations and group workshops, guided by the 2003 Lavis et al. KT framework that was improved by the Grimshaw et al. KT framework in 2012. Members of the Access 3 research team took on the role of knowledge brokers throughout the KT process. Participant satisfaction with the workshop was evaluated using a brief self-report survey. Policy uptake was determined through examination of the subsequent NSW Youth Health Framework 2017-2024.
A total of 25 policy recommendations were established through the workshop, and these were grouped into six themes that broadly aligned with the synthesized findings from the Access 3 project. The six policy themes were (1) technology solutions, (2) integrated care and investment to build capacity, (3) adolescent health checks, (4) workforce, (5) youth participation and (6) youth health indicators. Forum members were asked to vote on the importance of individual recommendations. These policy recommendations were subsequently presented to the NSW Ministry of Health, with some evidence of policy uptake identified. The majority of participants rated the forum positively.
The utilization of KT theories and active youth engagement led to the successful translation of research evidence and youth perspectives into NSW youth health policy. Future research should examine the implementation of policy arising from these KT efforts.
将证据和青年观点有效融入政策对于支持年轻人未来的健康和福祉至关重要。本项目的目的是将“Access 3”项目中的证据转化为支持澳大利亚新南威尔士州(NSW)制定新的青年健康与福祉政策的依据。确保年轻人在政策制定过程中的积极参与是知识转化(KT)过程的主要目标。
KT 活动包括为期一天的有组织论坛,共有 64 名有针对性抽样的利益相关者参加。参与者包括 8 名年轻人、14 名政策制定者、15 名学者、22 名来自新南威尔士州卫生服务部门的临床医生或管理人员、4 名全科医生和 1 名心理健康服务工作者。要转化的研究来源于“Access 3”项目的综合研究结果。论坛的设计包括利益相关者陈述和小组研讨会,以 2003 年 Lavis 等人的 KT 框架为指导,2012 年 Grimshaw 等人的 KT 框架进行了改进。“Access 3”研究团队成员在整个 KT 过程中担任知识经纪人。通过审查随后的 2017-2024 年新南威尔士州青年健康框架来确定政策采纳情况。
通过研讨会确立了 25 项政策建议,这些建议分为六个主题,大致与“Access 3”项目的综合研究结果一致。这六个政策主题是(1)技术解决方案、(2)综合护理和投资以建立能力、(3)青少年健康检查、(4)劳动力、(5)青年参与和(6)青年健康指标。论坛成员被要求对个别建议的重要性进行投票。随后将这些政策建议提交给新南威尔士州卫生部,确定了一些政策采纳的证据。大多数参与者对论坛评价积极。
利用 KT 理论和青年积极参与成功地将研究证据和青年观点转化为新南威尔士州青年健康政策。未来的研究应研究这些 KT 努力产生的政策实施情况。