Zhang Yingtao, Xian Min, Cheng Heng-Da, Shareef Bryar, Ding Jianrui, Xu Fei, Huang Kuan, Zhang Boyu, Ning Chunping, Wang Ying
School of Computer Science and Technology, Harbin Institute of Technology, Harbin 150001, China.
Department of Computer Science, University of Idaho, Idaho Falls, ID 83402, USA.
Healthcare (Basel). 2022 Apr 14;10(4):729. doi: 10.3390/healthcare10040729.
Breast ultrasound (BUS) image segmentation is challenging and critical for BUS computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) systems. Many BUS segmentation approaches have been studied in the last two decades, but the performances of most approaches have been assessed using relatively small private datasets with different quantitative metrics, which results in a discrepancy in performance comparison. Therefore, there is a pressing need for building a benchmark to compare existing methods using a public dataset objectively, to determine the performance of the best breast tumor segmentation algorithm available today, and to investigate what segmentation strategies are valuable in clinical practice and theoretical study. In this work, a benchmark for B-mode breast ultrasound image segmentation is presented. In the benchmark, (1) we collected 562 breast ultrasound images and proposed standardized procedures to obtain accurate annotations using four radiologists; (2) we extensively compared the performance of 16 state-of-the-art segmentation methods and demonstrated that most deep learning-based approaches achieved high dice similarity coefficient values (DSC ≥ 0.90) and outperformed conventional approaches; (3) we proposed the losses-based approach to evaluate the sensitivity of semi-automatic segmentation to user interactions; and (4) the successful segmentation strategies and possible future improvements were discussed in details.
乳腺超声(BUS)图像分割对于BUS计算机辅助诊断(CAD)系统而言具有挑战性且至关重要。在过去二十年中,人们对许多BUS分割方法进行了研究,但大多数方法的性能评估是使用相对较小的私有数据集,并采用不同的定量指标,这导致了性能比较上的差异。因此,迫切需要构建一个基准,以便使用公共数据集客观地比较现有方法,确定当今最佳乳腺肿瘤分割算法的性能,并研究哪些分割策略在临床实践和理论研究中具有价值。在这项工作中,我们提出了一个用于B型乳腺超声图像分割的基准。在该基准中,(1)我们收集了562幅乳腺超声图像,并提出了标准化程序,由四位放射科医生获得准确的标注;(2)我们广泛比较了16种先进分割方法的性能,结果表明,大多数基于深度学习的方法都获得了较高的骰子相似系数值(DSC≥0.90),并且优于传统方法;(3)我们提出了基于损失的方法来评估半自动分割对用户交互的敏感性;(4)详细讨论了成功的分割策略以及未来可能的改进方向。