Department of Computational Biology, University of Lausanne, Lausanne, Switzerland.
Swiss Institute of Bioinformatics, 1015, Lausanne, CH, Switzerland.
BMC Bioinformatics. 2022 Apr 22;23(1):147. doi: 10.1186/s12859-022-04672-4.
Over the past decade, experimental procedures such as metabolic labeling for determining RNA turnover rates at the transcriptome-wide scale have been widely adopted and are now turning to single cell measurements. Several computational methods to estimate RNA synthesis, processing and degradation rates from such experiments have been suggested, but they all require several RNA sequencing samples. Here we present a method that can estimate those three rates from a single sample.
Our method relies on the analytical solution to the Zeisel model of RNA dynamics. It was validated on metabolic labeling experiments performed on mouse embryonic stem cells. Resulting degradation rates were compared both to previously published rates on the same system and to a state-of-the-art method applied to the same data.
Our method is computationally efficient and outputs rates that correlate well with previously published data sets. Using it on a single sample, we were able to reproduce the observation that dynamic biological processes tend to involve genes with higher metabolic rates, while stable processes involve genes with lower rates. This supports the hypothesis that cells control not only the mRNA steady-state abundance, but also its responsiveness, i.e., how fast steady state is reached. Moreover, degradation rates obtained with our method compare favourably with the other tested method.
In addition to saving experimental work and computational time, estimating rates for a single sample has several advantages. It does not require an error-prone normalization across samples and enables the use of replicates to estimate uncertainty and assess sample quality. Finally the method and theoretical results described here are general enough to be useful in other contexts such as nucleotide conversion methods and single cell metabolic labeling experiments.
在过去的十年中,代谢标记等实验程序已被广泛应用于转录组范围内的 RNA 周转速率的测定,并且现在正转向单细胞测量。已经提出了几种从这些实验中估计 RNA 合成、加工和降解速率的计算方法,但它们都需要几个 RNA 测序样本。在这里,我们提出了一种可以从单个样本中估计这三个速率的方法。
我们的方法依赖于 RNA 动力学的 Zeisel 模型的解析解。它在对小鼠胚胎干细胞进行的代谢标记实验中进行了验证。得到的降解速率与同一系统上先前发表的速率以及应用于同一数据的最新方法进行了比较。
我们的方法计算效率高,输出的速率与先前发表的数据集相关性很好。在单个样本上使用它,我们能够重现这样的观察结果,即动态生物过程往往涉及代谢率较高的基因,而稳定的过程则涉及代谢率较低的基因。这支持了这样的假设,即细胞不仅控制 mRNA 的稳态丰度,还控制其反应性,即达到稳态的速度。此外,我们的方法得到的降解速率与其他测试方法相比具有优势。
除了节省实验工作和计算时间外,对单个样本进行速率估计还有几个优点。它不需要在样本之间进行容易出错的归一化,并且可以使用重复样本来估计不确定性和评估样本质量。最后,这里描述的方法和理论结果足够通用,可以在其他情况下使用,如核苷酸转换方法和单细胞代谢标记实验。