Meléndez-Flores J D, Irabien-Zuñiga M, Cerda-Contreras C, de Los Reyes-Calderón I, Estrada-Bellmann I
Hospital Universitario Doctor José E. González. Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León, Monterrey, México.
Facultad de Medicina, Universidad Autónoma de Nuevo León (UANL), Monterrey, México.
Rev Neurol. 2022 May 1;74(9):298-302. doi: 10.33588/rn.7409.2021518.
Studies have demonstrated a higher motor and non-motor burden in Parkinson's disease (PD) patients with old age at onset compared to those with middle age at onset. We decided to test these findings in a Latin American PD population.
We recruited 24 PD patients with age at onset > 65 years, and each patient was matched to 1 control patient with disease onset at ages between 48 and 60 years, matched for gender and disease duration (±2 years). Clinical test batteries that assessed motor (MDS-UPDRS), non-motor (NMSS), cognitive (MoCA), and quality of life (PDQ-8) were recorded. Groups were compared with conditional logistic regression analysis. A comparative post-hoc analysis was also conducted, considering only patients with age at onset > 70 years (n = 11) and their matched controls.
Mean age at onset was 70.53 ± 3.28 and 53.79 ± 4.96 for the old-age and middle-age group, respectively. No significant differences were observed in most clinical batteries when comparing PD patients based on age at onset, with worse scores in MDS-UPDRS Part III and Tremor subscore in the middle-age onset group. The post-hoc analysis showed similar results, with non-significantly worse scores in the middle-age onset group.
This is the first study reporting a more benign motor phenotype in old-age onset PD patients. Despite the lower cut-off value used for old age onset PD, vascular, epidemiological, ethnic and treatment adherence features must be also considered as potential explicative factors, with further multicenter studies in larger populations needed.
研究表明,与中年发病的帕金森病(PD)患者相比,老年发病的PD患者运动和非运动负担更高。我们决定在拉丁美洲的PD人群中验证这些发现。
我们招募了24例发病年龄>65岁的PD患者,为每位患者匹配1例发病年龄在48至60岁之间的对照患者,匹配因素包括性别和病程(±2年)。记录评估运动(MDS-UPDRS)、非运动(NMSS)、认知(MoCA)和生活质量(PDQ-8)的临床测试指标。采用条件逻辑回归分析比较两组。还进行了比较性事后分析,仅考虑发病年龄>70岁的患者(n = 11)及其匹配的对照。
老年组和中年组的平均发病年龄分别为70.53±3.28岁和53.79±4.96岁。根据发病年龄比较PD患者时,大多数临床指标未观察到显著差异,中年发病组在MDS-UPDRS第三部分和震颤子评分中的得分较差。事后分析显示了类似的结果,中年发病组的得分虽无显著差异但稍差。
这是第一项报道老年发病的PD患者运动表型更为良性的研究。尽管老年发病PD的年龄界定值较低,但血管、流行病学、种族和治疗依从性特征也必须被视为潜在的解释因素,需要在更大规模人群中进行进一步的多中心研究。