Hughes Kate E, Hughes Patrick G, Cahir Thomas, Plitt Jennifer, Ng Vivienne, Bedrick Edward, Ahmed Rami A
Emergency Medicine, University of Arizona College of Medicine, Tucson, Arizona, USA.
Emergency Medicine, Florida Atlantic University Charles E. Schmidt College of Medicine, Boca Raton, Florida, USA.
BMJ Simul Technol Enhanc Learn. 2019 Dec 20;6(4):235-238. doi: 10.1136/bmjstel-2019-000498. eCollection 2020.
Closed-loop communication (CLC) improves task efficiency and decreases medical errors; however, limited literature on strategies to improve real-time use exist. The primary objective was whether blindfolding a resuscitation leader was effective to improve crisis resource management (CRM) skills, as measured by increased frequency of CLC. Secondary objectives included whether blindfolding affected overall CRM performance or perceived task load. Participants included emergency medicine (EM) or EM/paediatric dual resident physicians. Participants completed presurveys, were block randomised into intervention (blindfolded) or control groups, lead both adult and paediatric resuscitations and completed postsurveys before debriefing. Video recordings of the simulations were reviewed by simulation fellowship-trained EM physicians and rated using the Ottawa CRM Global Rating Scale (GRS). Frequency of CLC was assessed by one rater via video review. Summary statistics were performed. Intraclass correlation coefficient was calculated. Data were analysed using R program for analysis of variance and regression analysis. There were no significant differences between intervention and control groups in any Ottawa CRM GRS category. Postgraduate year (PGY) significantly impacts all Ottawa GRS categories. Frequency of CLC use significantly increased in the blindfolded group (31.7, 95% CI 29.34 to 34.1) vs the non-blindfolded group (24.6, 95% CI 21.5 to 27.7). Participant's self-rated perceived NASA Task Load Index scores demonstrated no difference between intervention and control groups via a Wilcoxon rank sum test. Blindfolding the resuscitation leader significantly increases frequency of CLC. The blindfold code training exercise is an advanced technique that may increase the use of CLC.
闭环沟通(CLC)可提高任务效率并减少医疗差错;然而,关于改善实时使用策略的文献有限。主要目的是评估蒙住复苏领导者双眼是否能有效提高危机资源管理(CRM)技能,以CLC使用频率增加来衡量。次要目的包括蒙眼是否会影响整体CRM表现或感知到的任务负荷。参与者包括急诊医学(EM)或EM/儿科双科住院医师。参与者完成预调查,被整群随机分为干预组(蒙眼)或对照组,领导成人和儿科复苏,并在汇报前完成后调查。模拟的视频记录由接受过模拟培训的EM医生进行审查,并使用渥太华CRM全球评分量表(GRS)进行评分。CLC的频率由一名评估者通过视频审查进行评估。进行了汇总统计。计算了组内相关系数。使用R程序进行方差分析和回归分析。在渥太华CRM GRS的任何类别中,干预组和对照组之间均无显著差异。研究生年级(PGY)对所有渥太华GRS类别均有显著影响。与未蒙眼组(24.6,95%CI 21.5至27.7)相比,蒙眼组CLC使用频率显著增加(31.7,95%CI 29.34至34.1)。通过Wilcoxon秩和检验,参与者自评的NASA任务负荷指数得分在干预组和对照组之间无差异。蒙住复苏领导者的双眼显著增加了CLC的频率。蒙眼编码训练练习是一种可能会增加CLC使用的先进技术。