Department of Palliative Medicine, Faculty of Medicine and University Hospital Cologne, University of Cologne, Kerpener Straße 62, 50937, Cologne, Germany.
Palliative Care Unit, Department of Oncology, Hematology and BMT, University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, Martinistr. 52, 20246, Hamburg, Germany.
BMC Palliat Care. 2022 May 6;21(1):67. doi: 10.1186/s12904-022-00960-1.
Hospitals are globally an important place of care for dying people and the most frequent place of death in Germany (47%), but at the same time, the least preferred one - for both patients and their relatives. Important indicators and outcome variables indexing quality of care in the dying phase are available, and various proposals to achieve corresponding quality objectives exist. However, they are not yet sufficiently adapted to the heterogeneous needs of individual hospital wards.
This multi-centre single-arm pre-post study aims at the development and implementation of context-specific measures in everyday clinical practice, followed by evaluating this approach. Therefore, (1) already existing measures regarding optimal care in the dying phase are identified applying a systematic literature review as well as an online survey and a symposium with experts. Supported by the thereby generated collection of measures, (2) a stratified sample of ten teams of different wards from two university hospitals select suitable measures and implement them in their everyday clinical practice. Circumstances of patients' deaths on the selected wards are recorded twice, at baseline before application of the self-chosen measures and afterwards in a follow-up survey. Retrospective file analysis of deceased persons, quantitative staff surveys as well as qualitative multi-professional focus groups and interviews with relatives form the data basis of the pre-post evaluation. (3) Results are reviewed regarding their transferability to other hospitals and disseminated (inter-)nationally.
Measures that are easy to implement and appropriate to the specific situation are supposed to significantly improve the quality of care during the dying phase in hospitals and contribute to the well-being of dying patients and their relatives. Successful implementation of those measures requires consideration of the individual conditions and needs of patients and their relatives-but also of the health professionals-on the different hospital wards. Therefore, a bottom-up approach, in which the ward-specific situation is first analysed in detail and then the staff itself selects and implements measures to improve care, appears most promising for optimising care in the dying phase in hospitals.
The study is registered in the German Clinical Trials Register ( DRKS00025405 ).
医院是全球范围内临终关怀的重要场所,也是德国(47%)最常见的死亡地点,但同时也是患者及其家属最不愿意选择的地方。目前已经有一些重要的指标和结果变量可以用来评估临终关怀的质量,并且也有各种实现相应质量目标的建议。然而,这些建议尚未充分考虑到各个医院病房的异质需求。
本多中心单臂前后研究旨在为日常临床实践中制定和实施特定于情境的措施,并对该方法进行评估。因此,(1)通过系统文献回顾、在线调查以及与专家的研讨会,确定了有关临终关怀的现有措施。在此基础上,生成了一整套措施。(2)来自两家大学医院的十个不同病房的团队,从这些措施中选择合适的措施,并将其应用于日常临床实践中。在应用自选措施之前和之后的随访调查中,记录选定病房中患者死亡的情况。对死亡患者的病历进行回顾性分析、对员工进行定量调查、对多专业焦点小组进行定性分析以及对患者家属进行访谈,以此作为前后评估的基础。(3)对研究结果的可转移性进行审查,并在国内外进行传播。
易于实施且适合特定情况的措施有望显著提高医院临终关怀的质量,从而改善临终患者及其家属的幸福感。成功实施这些措施需要考虑患者及其家属的个体情况和需求,以及不同病房的卫生专业人员的情况。因此,自下而上的方法,即首先详细分析病房的具体情况,然后由工作人员自行选择和实施改善护理的措施,似乎是优化医院临终关怀的最有前途的方法。
本研究已在德国临床试验注册中心(DRKS00025405)注册。