Pham Thi Mui, Yin Mo, Cooper Ben S
Julius Center for Health Sciences and Primary Care, University Medical Center Utrecht, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Oxford Centre for Global Health Research, Nuffield Department of Medicine, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom.
Proc Math Phys Eng Sci. 2022 May;478(2261):20210746. doi: 10.1098/rspa.2021.0746. Epub 2022 May 11.
Hand hygiene is among the most fundamental and widely used behavioural measures to reduce the person-to-person spread of human pathogens and its effectiveness as a community intervention is supported by evidence from randomized trials. However, a theoretical understanding of the relationship between hand hygiene frequency and change in risk of infection is lacking. Using a simple model-based framework for understanding the determinants of hand hygiene effectiveness in preventing viral respiratory tract infections, we show that a crucial, but overlooked, determinant of the relationship between hand hygiene frequency and risk of infection via indirect transmission is persistence of viable virus on hands. If persistence is short, as has been reported for influenza, hand-washing needs to be performed very frequently or immediately after hand contamination to substantially reduce the probability of infection. When viable virus survival is longer (e.g. in the presence of mucus or for some enveloped viruses) less frequent hand washing can substantially reduce the infection probability. Immediate hand washing after contamination is consistently more effective than at fixed-time intervals. Our study highlights that recommendations on hand hygiene should be tailored to persistence of viable virus on hands and that more detailed empirical investigations are needed to help optimize this key intervention.
手部卫生是减少人类病原体人际传播的最基本且应用最广泛的行为措施之一,随机试验的证据支持了其作为一种社区干预措施的有效性。然而,目前缺乏对手部卫生频率与感染风险变化之间关系的理论理解。通过使用一个基于简单模型的框架来理解手部卫生在预防病毒性呼吸道感染方面有效性的决定因素,我们发现,手部卫生频率与通过间接传播感染风险之间关系的一个关键但被忽视的决定因素是手上存活病毒的持久性。如果持久性较短,如流感的情况,需要非常频繁地洗手或在手部污染后立即洗手,以大幅降低感染概率。当存活病毒的生存期较长时(例如在有黏液的情况下或对于某些包膜病毒),较少频率的洗手就能大幅降低感染概率。污染后立即洗手始终比按固定时间间隔洗手更有效。我们的研究强调,关于手部卫生的建议应根据手上存活病毒的持久性进行调整,并且需要更详细的实证研究来帮助优化这一关键干预措施。