Department of Psychiatry, Academic Medical Center University of Amsterdam, P.O. Box 22660, 1100 DD Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Alcohol Alcohol. 2022 Nov 11;57(6):664-673. doi: 10.1093/alcalc/agac027.
To clarify whether smoking interferes with successful treatment of alcohol use disorder (AUD).
The current systematic review investigates the potential moderating effect of smoking on behavioural and pharmacological treatment of AUD. In addition, this review summarizes the results of randomized controlled trials investigating the effect of smoking cessation treatments in subjects with AUD on drinking outcomes.
Overall, the results show that 16 out of the 31 pharmacological and psychotherapeutic alcohol treatment studies showed that being a non-smoker or decreased tobacco consumption during AUD treatment is associated with beneficial drinking outcomes, including reduced drinking, later relapse and prolonged alcohol abstinence. As such, smoking predicts poorer drinking outcomes in alcohol treatments. In the stop-smoking studies in patients with AUD, reduced smoking had virtually no effect on drinking behaviours. The inverse association between smoking and drinking outcome observed here indicates that non-smokers may be more successful to attain alcohol abstinence than smokers do. However, this association does not imply per se that smoking triggers alcohol consumption, since it can also mean that alcohol consumption promotes smoking.
It is concluded that (continued) tobacco smoking may have a negative moderating effect on the treatment outcome of AUD treatments. To optimize treatment outcome of AUD one may consider informing and counselling patients with AUD about the risks of smoking for treatment outcomes and offering support for smoking cessation.
阐明吸烟是否会干扰酒精使用障碍(AUD)的成功治疗。
本系统评价研究了吸烟对 AUD 的行为和药物治疗的潜在调节作用。此外,本综述总结了在 AUD 患者中进行的戒烟治疗对饮酒结果影响的随机对照试验的结果。
总体而言,结果表明,在 31 项药理学和心理治疗酒精治疗研究中,有 16 项研究表明,在 AUD 治疗期间不吸烟或减少烟草消费与有益的饮酒结果相关,包括减少饮酒、延迟复发和延长酒精禁欲。因此,吸烟预示着酒精治疗中较差的饮酒结果。在 AUD 患者的戒烟研究中,减少吸烟对饮酒行为几乎没有影响。这里观察到的吸烟与饮酒结果之间的反比关系表明,不吸烟者可能比吸烟者更成功地达到戒酒。然而,这种关联本身并不意味着吸烟会引发饮酒,因为它也可能意味着饮酒会促进吸烟。
可以得出结论,(持续)吸烟可能对 AUD 治疗的治疗结果产生负面调节作用。为了优化 AUD 的治疗结果,人们可以考虑告知和咨询 AUD 患者吸烟对治疗结果的风险,并为戒烟提供支持。