Lawrence Kate, Myrissa Kyriaki, Toribio-Mateas Miguel, Minini Lori, Gregory Alice M
Department of Psychology & Pedagogic Science, Faculty of Sport, Allied Health and Performance Science, St Mary's University, Twickenham, London, UK.
Department of Health Sciences, Faculty of Sport, Allied Health and Performance Science, St Mary's University, Twickenham, London, UK.
Pilot Feasibility Stud. 2022 May 23;8(1):108. doi: 10.1186/s40814-022-01058-4.
Dietary interventions have been previously explored in children with ADHD. Elimination diets and supplementation can produce beneficial behaviour changes, but little is known about the mechanisms mediating change. We propose that these interventions may work, in part, by causing changes in the gut microbiota. A microbiome-targeted dietary intervention was developed, and its feasibility assessed.
A non-randomised feasibility study was conducted on nine non-medicated children with ADHD, aged 8-13 years (mean 10.39 years), using a prospective one-group pre-test/post-test design. Participants were recruited from ADHD support groups in London and took part in the 6-week microbiome-targeted dietary intervention, which was specifically designed to impact the composition of gut bacteria. Children were assessed pre- and post-intervention on measures of ADHD symptomatology, cognition, sleep, gut function and stool-sample microbiome analysis. The primary aim was to assess the study completion rate, with secondary aims assessing adherence, adverse events (aiming for no severe and minimal), acceptability and suitability of outcome measures.
Recruitment proved to be challenging and despite targeting 230 participants directly through support groups, and many more through social media, nine families (of the planned 10) signed up for the trial. The completion rate for the study was excellent at 100%. Exploration of secondary aims revealed that (1) adherence to each aspect of the dietary protocol was very good; (2) two mild adverse events were reported; (3) parents rated the treatment as having good acceptability; (4) data collection and outcome measures were broadly feasible for use in an RCT with a few suggestions recommended; (5) descriptive data for outcome measures is presented and suggests that further exploration of gut microbiota, ADHD symptoms and sleep would be helpful in future research.
This study provides preliminary evidence for the feasibility of a microbiome-targeted dietary intervention in children with ADHD. Recruitment was challenging, but the diet itself was well-tolerated and adherence was very good. Families wishing to trial this diet may find it an acceptable intervention. However, recruitment, even for this small pilot study, was challenging. Because of the difficulty experienced recruiting participants, future randomised controlled trials may wish to adopt a simpler dietary approach which requires less parental time and engagement, in order to recruit the number of participants required to make meaningful statistical interpretations of efficacy.
ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT03737877 . Registered 13 November 2018-retrospectively registered, within 2 days of the first participant being recruited.
先前已对多动症儿童进行过饮食干预研究。排除饮食法和补充剂可产生有益的行为改变,但对于介导这些改变的机制知之甚少。我们认为,这些干预措施可能部分通过引起肠道微生物群的变化而起作用。因此,我们开发了一种针对微生物群的饮食干预方法,并评估了其可行性。
采用前瞻性单组预测试/后测试设计,对9名8至13岁(平均10.39岁)未接受药物治疗的多动症儿童进行了一项非随机可行性研究。参与者从伦敦的多动症支持小组招募,参加了为期6周的针对微生物群的饮食干预,该干预专门设计用于影响肠道细菌的组成。在干预前后,对儿童进行多动症症状、认知、睡眠、肠道功能和粪便样本微生物群分析等方面的评估。主要目的是评估研究完成率,次要目的是评估依从性、不良事件(目标是无严重不良事件且最少)、结果测量的可接受性和适用性。
招募工作颇具挑战性,尽管直接通过支持小组 targeted 230名参与者,并通过社交媒体招募了更多参与者,但计划中的10个家庭中有9个家庭报名参加了试验。该研究的完成率极佳,为100%。对次要目的的探索表明:(1)对饮食方案各方面的依从性非常好;(2)报告了两起轻度不良事件;(3)家长对治疗的可接受性评价良好;(4)数据收集和结果测量在随机对照试验中大致可行,并提出了一些建议;(5)列出了结果测量的描述性数据,表明未来研究中进一步探索肠道微生物群、多动症症状和睡眠将有所帮助。
本研究为针对多动症儿童的微生物群靶向饮食干预的可行性提供了初步证据。招募工作具有挑战性,但饮食本身耐受性良好,依从性也非常好。希望试用这种饮食的家庭可能会发现它是一种可接受的干预措施。然而,即使对于这个小型试点研究,招募工作也很有挑战性。由于在招募参与者时遇到困难,未来的随机对照试验可能希望采用一种更简单的饮食方法,这种方法需要家长花费更少的时间和精力参与,以便招募到能够对疗效进行有意义的统计解释所需的参与者数量。
ClinicalTrials.gov标识符:NCT03737877。于2018年11月13日注册——追溯注册,在第一名参与者招募后2天内。 (注:原文中“targeting 230 participants directly through support groups”这里“targeted”疑似拼写错误,应该是“targeting” )