Hillebrandt Annika, Saldanha Maria Francisca, Brady Daniel L, Barclay Laurie J
Ryerson University, Canada,
Universidade Católica Portuguesa, Portugal,
Hum Relat. 2022 Jul;75(7):1238-1269. doi: 10.1177/00187267211011000. Epub 2021 Apr 17.
What motivates managers to deliver bad news in a just manner and why do some managers fail to treat recipients of bad news with dignity and respect? Given the importance of delivering bad news in a just manner, answering these questions is critical to promote justice in the workplace. Drawing on appraisal theories of emotions, we propose that people with higher core self-evaluations may be less likely to deliver bad news in an interpersonally just manner. This is because these actors are more likely to appraise the delivery of bad news as a situation in which they have high coping potential and are therefore less likely to experience anxiety. However, we propose that anxiety can be important for propelling the enactment of interpersonal justice. We test our predictions across three studies (with four samples of full-time managers and employees). Theoretical and practical contributions include enhancing our understanding of is motivated to enact interpersonal justice, they are motivated to do so, and to enhance justice in the workplace. Our findings also challenge the assumption that negative emotions are necessarily dysfunctional for the enactment of interpersonal justice and instead highlight the facilitative role of anxiety in this context.
是什么促使管理者公正地传达坏消息,为什么有些管理者未能以尊严和尊重对待坏消息的接收者?鉴于公正传达坏消息的重要性,回答这些问题对于促进职场公正是至关重要的。借鉴情绪评估理论,我们提出,具有较高核心自我评价的人可能不太可能以人际公正的方式传达坏消息。这是因为这些行为者更有可能将传达坏消息评估为一种他们具有高应对潜力的情况,因此不太可能体验到焦虑。然而,我们提出焦虑对于推动人际公正的实施可能很重要。我们通过三项研究(对全职经理和员工的四个样本)来检验我们的预测。理论和实践贡献包括增进我们对谁有动机实施人际公正、他们为何有此动机以及如何增进职场公正的理解。我们的研究结果还挑战了负面情绪必然对人际公正的实施起功能失调作用这一假设,相反,突出了焦虑在这种情况下的促进作用。