Department of Radiology, Wake Forest University School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC 27157, USA.
Department of Biostatistics and Data Sciences, Division of Public Health Sciences, Wake Forest University School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC 27157, USA.
Neurotoxicol Teratol. 2022 Jul-Aug;92:107106. doi: 10.1016/j.ntt.2022.107106. Epub 2022 May 30.
Pesticide exposure remains a health hazard despite extensive study into adverse effects. Children in vulnerable populations, such as Latinx children in farmworker families, are particularly at risk for exposure. Several studies have demonstrated the detrimental cognitive effects of prenatal exposure to pesticides, particularly organophosphates (OPs) within this high-risk group. However, results from studies investigating the cognitive effects of early childhood pesticide exposure are equivocal. Most studies examining the effects of pesticide exposure have used correlative analyses rather than examining populations with expected high and low exposure. The current study compares 8-year-old children from rural families of farmworkers and urban, non-farmworker families. We used the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children - Fifth Edition (WISC-V) to assess cognitive performance in these children. We designed this study with the expectation that children from farmworker families would have greater exposure to agricultural pesticides than urban, non-farmworker children. This assumption of exposure to agricultural pesticides was confirmed in a recent report that assessed exposure probabilities using life history calendars. However, data from passive wristband sampling of acute (1-week) pesticide exposure from these same children indicate that both study populations have considerable pesticide exposure but to different chemicals. As expected the children of farmworkers had greater OP exposure than non-farmworker children, but the non-farmworker children had greater exposure to two other classes of insecticides (organochlorines [OCs] and pyrethroids). Our analyses considered these findings. A comparison of the cognitive scores between groups revealed that children from farmworker families had slightly higher performance on the Visual-Spatial Index (VSI) and Verbal Comprehension Index (VCI) when compared to children from non-farmworker families. Regression analyses where pesticide exposure was included as covariates revealed that OC exposure accounted for the largest portion of the group differences for both VSI and VCI. However, a post-hoc moderation analysis did not find significant interactions. The main study outcome was that the non-farmworker children exhibited lower WISC-V scores than the children from farmworker families, and the analyses incorporating pesticide exposure measures raise the hypothesis the that pervasive and persistent nature of a variety of pesticides may have adverse effects on the neurodevelopment of young Latinx children whether living in rural or non-farmworker environments.
尽管对农药的不良影响进行了广泛的研究,但农药暴露仍然是一个健康隐患。拉丁裔儿童等弱势群体中的儿童,尤其是在农业工人家庭中的儿童,特别容易受到农药暴露的影响。几项研究表明,产前接触农药,特别是高危人群中的有机磷农药(OPs),会对认知产生有害影响。然而,研究早期儿童接触农药对认知影响的结果存在争议。大多数研究农药暴露影响的研究都使用了相关分析,而不是检查预期高暴露和低暴露的人群。本研究比较了来自农业工人农村家庭和城市非农业工人家庭的 8 岁儿童。我们使用韦氏儿童智力量表第五版(WISC-V)评估这些儿童的认知表现。我们设计这项研究的预期是,农业工人家庭的儿童比城市非农业工人家庭的儿童有更多的农业农药接触。最近一份使用生活史日历评估暴露概率的报告证实了这种农业农药接触的假设。然而,来自这些相同儿童的急性(1 周)农药接触的被动腕带采样数据表明,两个研究人群都有相当多的农药接触,但接触的化学品不同。正如预期的那样,农业工人的孩子接触 OPs 的情况比非农业工人的孩子多,但非农业工人的孩子接触的另外两类杀虫剂(有机氯和拟除虫菊酯)更多。我们的分析考虑到了这些发现。将两组的认知得分进行比较后发现,与非农业工人家庭的孩子相比,农业工人家庭的孩子在视觉空间指数(VSI)和言语理解指数(VCI)上的表现略高。在将农药暴露作为协变量纳入回归分析后发现,OC 暴露解释了 VSI 和 VCI 两组间差异的最大部分。然而,事后的调节分析并未发现显著的交互作用。主要研究结果是,非农业工人家庭的孩子的 WISC-V 分数低于农业工人家庭的孩子,而纳入农药暴露措施的分析提出了这样一个假设,即各种农药的普遍和持久性质可能对年轻拉丁裔儿童的神经发育产生不利影响,无论他们生活在农村还是非农业工人环境中。