School of Art and Design, Dalian Polytechnic University, Dalian City, Liaoning Province, China.
Graduate School of Advanced Science and Technology, Japan Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, Nomi, Ishikawa, Japan.
PLoS One. 2022 Jun 3;17(6):e0269176. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0269176. eCollection 2022.
The quality of urban public spaces affects the emotional response of users; therefore, the emotional data of users can be used as indices to evaluate the quality of a space. Emotional response can be evaluated to effectively measure public space quality through affective computing and obtain evidence-based support for urban space renewal. We proposed a feasible evaluation method for multi-type urban public spaces based on multiple physiological signals and ensemble learning. We built binary, ternary, and quinary classification models based on participants' physiological signals and self-reported emotional responses through experiments in eight public spaces of five types. Furthermore, we verified the effectiveness of the model by inputting data collected from two other public spaces. Three observations were made based on the results. First, the highest accuracies of the binary and ternary classification models were 92.59% and 91.07%, respectively. After external validation, the highest accuracies were 80.90% and 65.30%, respectively, which satisfied the preliminary requirements for evaluating the quality of actual urban spaces. However, the quinary classification model could not satisfy the preliminary requirements. Second, the average accuracy of ensemble learning was 7.59% higher than that of single classifiers. Third, reducing the number of physiological signal features and applying the synthetic minority oversampling technique to solve unbalanced data improved the evaluation ability.
城市公共空间的质量会影响使用者的情绪反应;因此,可以将使用者的情绪数据作为评估空间质量的指标。通过情感计算来评估情绪反应,可有效衡量公共空间的质量,并为城市空间更新提供循证支持。我们提出了一种基于多生理信号和集成学习的多类型城市公共空间的可行性评价方法。通过在五种类型的八个公共空间中的实验,基于参与者的生理信号和自我报告的情绪反应,我们构建了二元、三元和五元分类模型。此外,我们还通过输入来自另外两个公共空间的数据来验证模型的有效性。根据结果得出了三个观察结果。首先,二元和三元分类模型的最高准确率分别为 92.59%和 91.07%。经过外部验证,最高准确率分别为 80.90%和 65.30%,这满足了评估实际城市空间质量的初步要求。然而,五元分类模型无法满足初步要求。其次,集成学习的平均准确率比单个分类器高 7.59%。第三,减少生理信号特征的数量并应用合成少数过采样技术解决数据不平衡问题,可提高评估能力。