Obaid Najla A
College of Pharmacy, Umm Al-Qura University, Makkah, Saudi Arabia.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2022 May 30;13:585-592. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S355950. eCollection 2022.
Group debate is an educational strategy meant to equip undergraduate students with enhanced communication skills as well as the understanding of complex topics. Many controversial topics in the microbiological field pose challenges to the pharmacist's ability to attribute a specific opinion to its supported clinical evidence and to discuss these topics with confidence.
A total of 76 second-year pharmacy students who enrolled in a PharmD program participated in the group debate as part of the student assessment in microbiology course. The students prepared selected topics on controversial issues in microbiology, which were presented as a debate. Post-debate questionnaire was distributed to the students and used to measure student perceptions.
The majority of the students (82.89%) demonstrated an improvement in their understanding of the topics after the debate. The highest percentage was recorded from one topic group (97.37%) which stated that they had improved understanding after the debate. About a third of the total students reported great improvement in their communication skills.
This debate group clearly provided the students with high confidence in presenting their arguments from relevant scientific information gathered from existing literature. It also enhanced their understanding of complex and controversial microbiology topics that will be needed during their pharmacy education.
小组辩论是一种教育策略,旨在使本科生具备更强的沟通技巧以及对复杂主题的理解能力。微生物学领域的许多争议性话题对药剂师根据支持性临床证据形成特定观点并自信地讨论这些话题的能力构成挑战。
共有76名注册药学博士课程的二年级药学专业学生参加了小组辩论,作为微生物学课程学生评估的一部分。学生们准备了微生物学中有争议问题的选定主题,并以辩论的形式呈现。辩论后向学生发放问卷,用于衡量学生的看法。
大多数学生(82.89%)在辩论后对主题的理解有所提高。一个主题组的记录比例最高(97.37%),称他们在辩论后理解有所提高。约三分之一的学生报告称沟通技巧有很大提高。
这个辩论小组显然使学生们能够高度自信地根据从现有文献中收集的相关科学信息来阐述他们的论点。它还增强了他们对药学教育中所需的复杂且有争议的微生物学主题的理解。