Watanabe Noriyuki, Ishikawa Eiichi, Sugii Narushi, Sakakura Kazuki, Matsuda Masahide, Kohzuki Hidehiro, Tsurubuchi Takao, Masuda Yosuke, Zaboronok Alexander, Kino Hiroyoshi, Hayakawa Mikito, Takano Shingo, Matsumaru Yuji, Akutsu Hiroyoshi
Department of Neurosurgery, Faculty of Medicine, University of Tsukuba, Tsukuba, JPN.
Epileptic Center, University of Tsukuba Hospital, Tsukuba, JPN.
Cureus. 2022 May 10;14(5):e24894. doi: 10.7759/cureus.24894. eCollection 2022 May.
Background Brain tumor patients tend to develop postoperative epileptic seizures, which can lead to an unfavorable outcome. Although the incidence of postoperative epileptic seizures and adverse events are improved with the advent of levetiracetam (LEV), postoperative epilepsy occurs at a frequency of 4.6% or higher. In brain tumor patients, the addition of sodium channel blockers (SCBs) to LEV significantly reduces seizures, though confirmed in a non-postoperative study. Thus, the combination of SCBs with LEV might be promising. Objective In this prospective randomized controlled trial we investigated the safety, evaluated by adverse events during one and two weeks after surgery, and the efficacy, evaluated by the incidence of early epilepsy, including non-convulsive status epilepticus (NCSE), of using LEV alone or SCBs added to LEV in patients who underwent craniotomy or biopsy for brain tumors or brain mass lesions. Methods Patients with brain tumors or brain mass lesions undergoing surgical interventions, excluding endoscopic endonasal surgery (EES), with a diagnosis of epilepsy were eligible for this study. Patients are randomized into either Group A or B (B1 or B2) after the informed consents are taken; LEV alone in Group A patients, while LEV and SCBs in Group B patients (GroupB1, intravenous fosphenytoin plus oral lacosamide (LCM) and GroupB2, intravenous LCM plus oral LCM) were administered postoperatively. Fifty-three patients were enrolled during the first two and a half years of the study and four of them were excluded, resulting in the accumulation of 49 patients' data. Results Postoperative epileptic seizures occurred only in three out of 49 patients during the first week (6.1%) and in seven patients within two weeks after surgery (14.3%, including the three patients during the first week). In Group A, epileptic seizures occurred in two out of 26 patients during the first week (7.7%) and in five patients within two weeks (19.2%) after surgery. In Group B, epileptic seizures occurred in one out of 23 patients during the first week (4.3%) and in two patients during the first two weeks (8.7%). Low complication grade of epileptic seizures was observed in Group B rather than in Group A, however, without significant difference (p=0.256). There was no difference in the frequency of adverse effects in each group. Conclusion Although not statistically significant, the incidence of epileptic seizures within one week after surgery was lesser in LEV+SCBs groups than in LEV alone. No hepatic damage or renal function worsening occurred with the addition of LCM, suggesting the safety of LEV+SCBs therapy.
脑肿瘤患者术后容易发生癫痫发作,这可能导致不良后果。尽管随着左乙拉西坦(LEV)的出现,术后癫痫发作和不良事件的发生率有所改善,但术后癫痫的发生率仍在4.6%或更高。在脑肿瘤患者中,在非术后研究中证实,在LEV基础上加用钠通道阻滞剂(SCBs)可显著减少癫痫发作。因此,SCBs与LEV联合使用可能很有前景。目的:在这项前瞻性随机对照试验中,我们研究了在接受开颅手术或脑肿瘤或脑肿块病变活检的患者中,单独使用LEV或在LEV基础上加用SCBs的安全性(通过术后1周和2周内的不良事件评估)和疗效(通过早期癫痫的发生率评估,包括非惊厥性癫痫持续状态(NCSE))。方法:接受手术干预(不包括鼻内镜手术(EES))且诊断为癫痫的脑肿瘤或脑肿块病变患者符合本研究条件。在获得知情同意后,将患者随机分为A组或B组(B1或B2);A组患者单独使用LEV,而B组患者术后给予LEV和SCBs(B1组,静脉注射磷苯妥英钠加口服拉科酰胺(LCM);B2组,静脉注射LCM加口服LCM)。在研究的前两年半中招募了53例患者,其中4例被排除,最终积累了49例患者的数据。结果:49例患者中,仅3例在术后第一周发生癫痫发作(6.1%),7例在术后两周内发生癫痫发作(14.3%,包括第一周的3例)。A组中,26例患者中有2例在术后第一周发生癫痫发作(7.7%),5例在术后两周内发生癫痫发作(19.2%)。B组中,23例患者中有1例在术后第一周发生癫痫发作(4.3%),2例在术后两周内发生癫痫发作(8.7%)。B组癫痫发作的并发症等级低于A组,但差异无统计学意义(p=0.256)。各组不良反应的发生率无差异。结论:虽然无统计学意义,但LEV+SCBs组术后1周内癫痫发作的发生率低于单独使用LEV组。加用LCM未发生肝损害或肾功能恶化,提示LEV+SCBs治疗的安全性。