Baum S A, Rubenstein L Z
J Am Geriatr Soc. 1987 May;35(5):398-404. doi: 10.1111/j.1532-5415.1987.tb04660.x.
Little is known about how the care received in emergency departments (ED) by the elderly population differs from that received by younger people. We prospectively abstracted ED records of 1620 consecutive patients visiting a large community hospital ED over a 22-day period in 1984 for demographic and medical variables. Charts of patients presenting with five specific complaints (dyspnea, chest pain, abdominal pain, syncope, and motor vehicle accidents) were also analyzed for process of care variables and, for patients hospitalized, the accuracy of the ED diagnosis. Older people (ie, those greater than or equal to 65 years of age) do not seem to be overutilizers of the ED for minor complaints, in fact, they tend to be more acutely ill on presentation than younger people. Older people were more likely to be hospitalized (46% v 10%, P less than .001), to arrive by ambulance (35% v 10%, P less than .001), and to have an identified source of primary care (95% v 64%, P less than .01). Older people stayed longer in the ED than younger people if they were eventually released home but shorter if admitted to the hospital. Test ordering patterns for specific complaints varied by patient age (eg, older patients had more electrocardiograms performed for chest pain and fewer urinalyses for abdominal pain than younger patients). Therapy for specific complaints showed less age effect. Although generally more diagnostic tests were performed on older patients, the ED diagnosis tended to be more accurate for younger patients. Our data indicate that the process of ED care may be substantially different for the elderly population and have implications for future planning and financing of medical care.
关于老年人群在急诊科接受的护理与年轻人接受的护理有何不同,目前所知甚少。1984年,我们前瞻性地提取了一家大型社区医院急诊科连续22天就诊的1620例患者的急诊科记录,以获取人口统计学和医学变量信息。还对出现五种特定主诉(呼吸困难、胸痛、腹痛、晕厥和机动车事故)的患者病历进行了护理过程变量分析,对于住院患者,还分析了急诊科诊断的准确性。老年人(即年龄大于或等于65岁的人)似乎并非因轻微不适而过度使用急诊科,事实上,他们就诊时往往比年轻人病情更危急。老年人更有可能住院(46%对10%,P<0.001)、乘坐救护车前来(35%对10%,P<0.001),并且有确定的初级保健来源(95%对64%,P<0.01)。如果最终出院回家,老年人在急诊科停留的时间比年轻人长,但如果住院则较短。针对特定主诉的检查医嘱模式因患者年龄而异(例如,老年患者因胸痛进行心电图检查的次数比年轻患者多,因腹痛进行尿液分析的次数比年轻患者少)。针对特定主诉的治疗显示出较小的年龄效应。虽然一般来说对老年患者进行的诊断检查更多,但急诊科对年轻患者的诊断往往更准确。我们的数据表明,老年人群的急诊科护理过程可能有很大不同,这对未来医疗护理的规划和融资具有重要意义。